A Home Office release says nearly 80 percent of detained slavery referrals are not genuine. Its own new data, released the same week, shows detained claimants are confirmed as victims at under half the non-detained rate.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. A Home Office press release marking the Immigration and Asylum Bill's Commons Third Reading says "nearly 80% of individuals referred into the modern slavery system while held in detention last year were not ultimately identified as a victim" [1]. The department's own data tables, published the day before, show referrals from people in detention were confirmed as genuine, a positive conclusive grounds decision, in 18.0 percent of 2025 cases, against 40.9 percent for referrals from people not in detention, more than double the detained rate [4]. The same release says a new clause will "scrap" the five working days' notice given before removal and replace it with "a 6-month period... before further notice is required" [1]; the clause itself, Report stage New Clause 10, keeps that five day notice as a legal precondition and instead extends an unrelated 21 day window for re-attempting a failed removal to six months [2], a change the Bill's 130 page impact assessment, finalised five months earlier, never mentions [3]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
The vote itself was not close: 290 to 94, a majority of 196, sending the Bill to the House of Lords [1]. Third Reading itself took place the day before the release, on 17 November; 18 November, the date on the release, is when the Bill had its First Reading in the Lords, a formality rather than a vote [6]. The Home Office's release spends most of its length on that margin and on the Home Secretary's wider record: "small boat arrivals down, returns of those here illegally at a decade long high and costs to the taxpayer falling by £1 billion" [1]. Lower down, two further changes made at Report stage get the same confident treatment as the vote count. trackedchanges tested this Bill's factsheets against its own impact assessment in October and found the department's headline savings claim did not survive contact with its own costed numbers [3]. The two claims below were added after that assessment closed, and deserve the same test.
What the release says
On modern slavery, the release states: "The government is committed to ensuring that decisions made under the National Referral Mechanism are robust and that the system effectively identifies and supports those it is intended to protect. Nearly 80% of individuals referred into the modern slavery system while held in detention last year were not ultimately identified as a victim" [1]. It adds that detained referrals were "a quarter" of the 18,265 immigration related NRM referrals in 2025, a specific and checkable figure: 4,526 [1].
On removal, the release says enforced returns "can only take place after a minimum notice period of 5 working days, which often acts as a trigger for further last-minute claims, delaying a legitimate removal," and that "the proposed amendment will scrap this timeframe, and officers will instead be given a 6-month period to remove failed asylum seekers and illegal migrants before further notice is required" [1].
Both claims are specific enough to check against documents the department has itself published.
The claims, tested
| The release's own words | What the cited evidence actually shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "Nearly 80% of individuals referred into the modern slavery system while held in detention last year were not ultimately identified as a victim," cited as part of "wider efforts to reduce opportunities for improper use of the system" [1] | The Home Office's own ad hoc release, published the day before, breaks 2025 NRM referrals down by detention status. Of 4,526 referrals from people in detention, 814 ended in a positive conclusive grounds decision, a confirmed victim: 18.0 percent. Of 13,739 referrals from people not in detention, 5,619 were confirmed, 40.9 percent, more than double the detained rate [4]. People referred from detention were also screened out at the first stage, a reasonable grounds decision, far more often: 61.4 percent (2,777 of 4,526), against 39.4 percent (5,417 of 13,739) outside detention [4]. The Home Office's own notes on this dataset say only that non-immigration detention cases "are more likely to be left open for longer periods of time" [4]; nothing in the published tables says how much of the gap reflects the merits of the claims rather than the circumstances in which they are decided | The 80 percent figure is accurate, if anything slightly understated (82 percent on the department's own numbers). But the release uses it to frame referrals made in detention as disproportionately false, without mentioning that its own, same week data shows detained claimants are confirmed as victims at under half the rate of everyone else and screened out at the first hurdle far more often, a pattern the release does not attempt to explain |
| "Currently, enforced returns for these individuals can only take place after a minimum notice period of 5 working days... The proposed amendment will scrap this timeframe, and officers will instead be given a 6-month period to remove failed asylum seekers and illegal migrants before further notice is required" [1] | New Clause 10, tabled by the Home Secretary at Report stage on 17 November, inserts a new section 10ZA into the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999. It keeps the five working day "notice of intention to remove" as a precondition for removing someone who has exhausted their appeal rights before the new tribunal: a person may be removed "if... at least five working days before the day on which their appeal rights became exhausted, the Secretary of State or an immigration officer has given them a notice of intention to remove" [2]. The number that actually changes, from 21 days to six months, sits in different sections, 10B and 10E: the window officials get to re-attempt a removal that has already failed, or to remove someone after losing a judicial review, without serving a fresh notice [2]. The Bill's own 130 page impact assessment, finalised 30 June, five months before this clause was tabled, does not mention it: a direct search of the document for "notice period," "working day" or "10AZ" returns nothing [3] | The release's own words describe the five day notice as the thing being scrapped and replaced by a six month period. The clause does the opposite: the five day notice survives, and what moves to six months is an unrelated retry window for removals that have already failed once, introduced after the Bill's formal evidence base was already closed |
Credit where due
The "decade long high" returns claim checks out on the department's own published statistics: voluntary returns, 30,936 in the year ending June 2026, are the highest in over ten years, and asylum related returns are the highest since that statistical series began in 2010 [5]. The underlying NRM detention breakdown was published candidly, the same week as the release that cites the headline figure drawn from it, not months later or only on request [4]. New Clause 10 also leaves judicial review itself untouched: section 10E, which the clause amends, remains in force, and only the notice window around a failed judicial review changes, not the right to bring one [2]. And the 290 to 94 vote is reported accurately, down to the 196 majority [1].
The mistakes, counted
A referral statistic is used to suggest detained claims are less genuine, without the department's own comparator (1). The release's "nearly 80%" figure for detained modern slavery referrals is accurate. But the same week's data tables show referrals from people not in detention are confirmed as genuine at more than double the rate, 40.9 percent against 18.0 percent, and that detained referrals are screened out at the first stage far more often too [4]. The release cites the detention figure to justify tightening the rules for exactly that group, without engaging the comparison its own data invites.
A notice period change is described backwards: the clause said to scrap the five day notice keeps it, and extends a different number instead (2). The release says the five working day minimum notice is being "scrapped" and replaced by a six month period [1]. New Clause 10 keeps that five day notice as a precondition for removal and instead extends a separate 21 day retry window, for removals that have already failed once, to six months [2]. The Bill's own impact assessment, closed five months before this clause was tabled, says nothing about it either way [3].
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. The vote was genuine, the returns figures hold up, and the department published the detention breakdown that complicates its own case in the same week as the release that cites it. But a press release is the version of a Bill most people will read, and this one uses a real statistic to imply detained modern slavery claims are unusually weak without mentioning its own data's clearest explanation, and describes a five day notice as scrapped when the clause in front of Parliament leaves it standing and extends something else entirely. A reader who stops at the release comes away with both the wrong picture and the wrong number.
Sources
- Home Secretary's landmark immigration reforms clear latest hurdle, Home Office and The Rt Hon Shabana Mahmood MP, published 18 November 2026
- New Clause 10, "Notice in advance of removal", Report stage amendment, Immigration and Asylum Bill, UK Parliament, tabled 17 November 2026
- Immigration and Asylum Bill, Impact Assessment, Home Office, HO IA 1029, 30 June 2026
- Intersection between the National Referral Mechanism and the Immigration system, 2025, Home Office, published 17 November 2026
- How many people are returned from the UK, Immigration system statistics, year ending June 2026, Home Office, published 27 August 2026
- Immigration and Asylum Bill: stages, UK Parliament Bills API, Bill 4254