The High Court found the Office for Students had a closed mind when it fined Sussex 585,000 pounds over free speech. Its new rulebook on the same duties, out for consultation, never mentions that finding.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
In short. On 20 April 2026 the government announced that the Office for Students would get new powers to fine universities up to 500,000 pounds or 2 percent of income, or deregister them, for breaching free speech duties from April 2027 [2]. Nine days later, on 29 April 2026, the High Court quashed the OfS's existing 585,000 pound fine against the University of Sussex, ruling the regulator's finding of breach "was vitiated by bias because the OfS approached the decision with a closed mind and had therefore unlawfully predetermined the decision" [1]. The OfS is now consulting, until 23 November 2026, on the guidance for the new conditions that will carry those fines [3]. Its 74-page consultation document cites the Sussex judgment exactly once, on page 9, to adopt a narrower definition of one disputed term [3]. The monitoring and enforcement sections for both new conditions, on pages 34 and 38, propose relying on "its general risk-based approach to monitoring and intervention as set out in the regulatory framework" [3], the same framework and investigatory process the court found had produced a predetermined outcome. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Freedom of speech duties for English universities tightened twice in short succession this year. The Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023 duties came into force in August 2025, and on 20 April 2026 the government announced the enforcement teeth to go with them: a new OfS complaints scheme from June 2026, and, from April 2027, new registration conditions carrying fines of "500,000 pounds or 2% of their income, whichever is higher, or in the most serious cases, could be deregistration which involves losing access to student support funding or public grant funding" [2]. The OfS's consultation on the guidance for those new conditions, E11 and E12, runs from 17 September to 23 November 2026 and will apply to every provider on the OfS register, a population the OfS's own most recent financial sustainability report puts at 279 providers teaching "nearly 2.1 million full-time equivalent (FTE) students" in 2024-25 (page 7) [4].
Nine days after the enforcement announcement, the OfS lost a case that tested exactly this kind of power. The High Court's press summary of the judgment sets out what the OfS actually did to the University of Sussex: fined it 585,000 pounds on 27 March 2025 for breaching its existing public interest governance conditions over a trans and non-binary equality policy statement and a free speech code of practice [1]. Mrs Justice Lieven found for the university on jurisdiction, on the meaning of the duties, and on bias. Her conclusion on the last point is unambiguous: "the finding of breach in relation to both conditions was vitiated by bias because the OfS approached the decision with a closed mind and had therefore unlawfully predetermined the decision" [1].
What the court actually found wrong
The press summary is specific about the mechanism, not just the outcome. It records that the OfS's board resolved, in September 2021, to "proactively seek cases to pursue using our investigatory powers," and that the chief executive's own evidence described wanting a case that would "send a strong signal" and create "clear compliance incentives" (paragraphs 366-367) [1]. The court found the OfS unlawfully predetermined the outcome for four further reasons: its overarching strategy from the opening of the investigation to find a "test case"; its conduct in settlement talks, where it "assumed a breach before the Provisional Decision was reached" and refused to meet the university unless it accepted the alleged breaches in full; writing to other universities using the same policy template to highlight the breach and fine only after the final decision was published; and a failure to properly weigh the university's own free speech code of practice (paragraphs 428-436) [1]. The court also found that although the decision was formally made by an independent compliance committee, that committee "adopted" the investigation team's draft decision "in its entirety," with "no evidence of sufficient independent consideration" to remove the closed-mind approach (paragraphs 439-443) [1]. Every one of those findings is about process: how the OfS opens investigations, negotiates, and checks its own draft decisions, not about the wording of the conditions it was enforcing.
The consultation's one citation
The OfS's consultation document does engage with the judgment, once. In the explanation for condition E11.1, it states: "In light of the judgment in the University of Sussex v the Office for Students, we have adopted a definition of 'governing documents' to mean 'governing documents that have some governing effect, which goes to the constitution or governance of the higher education provider'" (page 9) [3]. That is a real fix to a real problem the court identified: the OfS had wrongly treated Sussex's policy statement as a "governing document" under the statute, and the new definition narrows the term to match the court's reading [1].
But that fix addresses only the first of the five grounds the university won on. A search of the full 74-page consultation document for the specific findings behind the bias ruling, the words "closed mind," "predetermin," "bias," "test case," "strong signal," or any reference to the compliance committee that adopted the investigation team's draft decision without independent scrutiny, returns nothing. The monitoring and enforcement sections for both new conditions are near-identical boilerplate. For E11: "The OfS will use its general risk-based approach to monitoring and intervention as set out in the regulatory framework," followed by three options "in any order," ending with "use its regulatory and/or investigatory powers where it is considered appropriate for any reason" (page 34) [3]. For E12: the same "general risk-based approach to monitoring," the same three options, the same closing line (page 38) [3]. Neither passage says anything about how an investigation is opened, how settlement talks are conducted, or how the decision-making committee tests the investigation team's draft before adopting it, the exact three mechanisms the court's press summary says produced a predetermined decision.
The claims, tested
| What the OfS says it has done | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "In light of the judgment in the University of Sussex v the Office for Students, we have adopted a definition of 'governing documents'" (page 9) [3] | The judgment's press summary records five separate grounds the OfS lost on; the definition of "governing documents" was one of them (Issue 1) [1] | The consultation engages with one of five grounds and presents it as its response to "the judgment" as a whole |
| New E11 and E12 monitoring and enforcement guidance proposes "its general risk-based approach to monitoring and intervention as set out in the regulatory framework" (pages 34 and 38) [3] | The court found that approach, applied to Sussex, produced a strategy to find a "test case," one-sided settlement conduct, and a compliance committee that adopted the investigation team's draft "in its entirety" with no independent scrutiny (paragraphs 428-443) [1] | The guidance for conditions carrying fines of up to 500,000 pounds proposes the identical process the court found unlawful, with no stated change |
Credit where due
The OfS did not have to mention the Sussex judgment at all in a consultation about different, newer conditions, and it chose to. The definitional fix it made is a genuine, specific response to a genuine, specific legal error, not a cosmetic gesture: narrowing "governing documents" to instruments with constitutional or governance effect directly answers the court's own reasoning on Issue 1 [1] [3]. The consultation is also open about the limits of what it is consulting on: it says plainly that the wording of the new conditions themselves is fixed by statute and not up for discussion, and separates that from the guidance questions where it says it does want views (pages 6-7) [3]. Nothing here disputes that the OfS was entitled to lose this case and respond to part of it; the finding below is only that the response, on its own text, stops short of the part of the judgment that caused the fine to be quashed.
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. The Office for Students is about to acquire the power to fine universities 500,000 pounds or 2 percent of income, or deregister them, for breaching free speech duties, using a monitoring and investigation process it has not proposed to change. Weeks before those powers were announced, the High Court found that exact process, run by the exact regulator, had produced a decision vitiated by bias and unlawful predetermination against a university that ultimately won. A consultation that cites the judgment to fix one definition, while silently carrying forward the investigatory strategy, settlement conduct and committee sign-off the court specifically criticised, is not a response to what the court actually found. Any university that disputes an OfS finding under the new conditions from April 2027 will be tested by the same process Sussex was, with the same fine-level stakes and no stated safeguard against the same result.
The star score counts two documented mistakes: the consultation's only citation of the Sussex judgment addresses one of the five grounds the OfS lost on (the definition of "governing documents," page 9), while presenting this as a response to "the judgment" without qualification; and the monitoring and enforcement guidance proposed for both new conditions (pages 34 and 38) repeats the "general risk-based approach to monitoring and intervention" the OfS used against Sussex, with no proposed change to the investigatory strategy, settlement conduct or committee scrutiny the court's press summary (paragraphs 428-443) found had produced a predetermined decision. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding that the new E11 and E12 conditions are unlawful, or that the OfS's general risk-based monitoring approach is wrong in every case; the finding is narrower, that the specific process failures a court has already identified in this regulator's use of this kind of power are not addressed in the guidance for the next version of that power. Checked directly against the OfS's consultation document (74 pages, published 17 September 2026), the judiciary's press summary of the Sussex judgment (6 pages, published 29 April 2026), the government's 20 April 2026 announcement of the new powers, and the OfS's Financial sustainability report 2026, all fetched 11 November 2026.
Sources
- Press Summary: The University of Sussex v The Office for Students, [2026] EWHC 984 (Admin) (PDF), Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, 29 April 2026
- New powers to protect vital free speech at universities, GOV.UK, 20 April 2026
- Consultation on new free speech conditions of registration, Office for Students, 17 September 2026
- Financial sustainability of higher education providers in England 2026 (PDF), Office for Students