TEARDOWN Published 14 November 2026 at 05:24. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The Gambling Commission brands its new illegal-gambling index a robust measure of enforcement success. The one figure testing whether a crackdown worked, the index admits, is still a work in progress.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Victoria Square House, Birmingham, the Gambling Commission's registered office.
Victoria Square House, Birmingham, 2026. The Gambling Commission gives this address as its Birmingham office for correspondence. Photo: Jeff Gogarty / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In short. The Gambling Commission's Illegal Gambling Data Dashboard for November 2026 describes its own composite index as "a robust and iterative measure for monitoring consumer engagement over time" [1]. The same document states that its website count "is not a complete count of the illegal market", that its traffic figures "are modelled estimates rather than directly observed traffic, and coverage may be limited for smaller websites", and that its disruption-impact metrics, the figures measuring whether enforcement actually works, are "a developing area of work which will be strengthened as further work is undertaken" [1]. The Commission's companion press release, published for the first Illegal Gambling Awareness Week, points to that same dashboard as "further evidence to support enforcement activity and track progress in disrupting illegal markets" [2]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

Illegal Gambling Awareness Week ran from 9 to 13 November 2026, the first outing of a new international campaign led by the International Association of Gaming Regulators. The Gambling Commission used it to announce it was "widening the net": not just taking down illegal websites, but chasing the money behind them [2]. The announcement leaned on numbers. More than 1,000 cease and desist notices issued so far this financial year, 7.8 million URLs referred to search engines, 2,200 websites referred for disruption action, and £40 million in suspected criminal funds referred to partner agencies for potential asset freezing since January [2]. Sue Young, the Commission's Executive Director of Operations, put it plainly: "If you run an illegal gambling operation, we are coming after you, your business and your money" [2].

The press release does not rest on enforcement activity alone. It names its source of proof that the activity is working: "IGAW kicks off after publication last week of new findings from the Gambling Survey for Great Britain and an updated illegal gambling dashboard which provide further evidence to support enforcement activity and track progress in disrupting illegal markets" [2]. That dashboard, published four days earlier on 5 November, is the Commission's own document. Read in full, it tells a more careful story than the press release's headline numbers suggest.

What the index calls itself

The dashboard's Illegal Gambling Index combines behavioural indicators of illegal-gambling website use, built by the Commission with Yonder Consulting. The document's own description of it is confident: it "provides the Commission with a robust and iterative measure for monitoring consumer engagement over time" [1]. On that measure, the dashboard reports that 586 illegal gambling websites were identified as accessible to consumers in Great Britain in September 2026, and that estimated engagement with those sites was 12% greater than the previous three-month average [1].

What the same document admits

Three paragraphs cover the three building blocks of that index, and each carries its own limitation, in the Commission's own words. On the website count: "The measure reflects sites found through this monitoring method and is not a complete count of the illegal market" [1]. On the traffic estimates behind the engagement figures: "Similarweb figures are modelled estimates rather than directly observed traffic, and coverage may be limited for smaller websites. The measure should therefore be interpreted as an indicator of scale and trend, rather than a precise estimate" [1]. To cover gambling activity hidden behind a VPN, the Commission applies what it calls a "graduated uplift", adding 19% to its lower-bound estimate, 26% to the point estimate and 34% to the upper bound, a range the document says exists because of "uncertainty about the prevalence of VPN use among individuals accessing illegal gambling websites that is not captured by this methodology" [1].

The third building block is the one the press release leans on hardest. "Our disruption impact metrics are a developing area of work which will be strengthened as further work is undertaken to develop our tracking of consumer engagement with the illegal market" [1]. That is the Commission's own description of the metrics behind its headline disruption claims: 311 illegal gambling websites had disruption action taken against them in the second quarter of the 2026-27 financial year, 38% more than the previous quarter; 77% of disrupted websites experienced a reduction in estimated traffic following disruption activity, 26 percentage points higher than the previous quarter; and an 18% reduction in total estimated web traffic was observed for disrupted websites [1].

The claims, tested

The Commission's own words What the same document shows Verdict
The Illegal Gambling Index "provides the Commission with a robust and iterative measure for monitoring consumer engagement over time" [1] Its three components are each separately qualified: website counts are "not a complete count"; traffic figures are "modelled estimates rather than directly observed"; a VPN uplift of 19 to 34% covers a gap "not captured by this methodology" [1] Headline figures (12% engagement rise, 53% less search volume) are reported to the percentage point despite methodology the document itself calls modelled and incomplete
The press release cites the dashboard as "further evidence to support enforcement activity and track progress in disrupting illegal markets" [2], pointing to 311 disruptions and a 77% traffic-reduction rate The dashboard's own methodology section says of exactly that category: "Our disruption impact metrics are a developing area of work which will be strengthened as further work is undertaken" [1] The one metric that actually tests whether disruption works is the one the Commission itself says is not yet mature

Credit where due

The Commission did not bury any of this. The caveats sit in the same published document as the headline figures, under their own methodology notes, rather than in a technical appendix a reader would need to hunt for; a regulator that hides its uncertainty would not write "is not a complete count" into its own key-facts page. The enforcement numbers themselves are specific rather than vague: 1,000-plus cease and desist notices, a named 38% quarter-on-quarter rise in disruptions, and a £40 million referral figure tied to a stated start date (January) rather than an unbounded "millions". Publishing a monthly dashboard with this level of granularity at all, rather than an annual summary, is more transparency than most regulators volunteer.

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes. A regulator calling its own measurement tool "robust" is not, on its own, a problem; every index has limits, and naming them is good practice. The problem is that the two documents work against each other on timing. One four-day-old document builds a public enforcement narrative, "follow the money", "coming after you, your business and your money", explicitly citing the dashboard as its evidentiary backing. The dashboard it cites says, about the single component that would actually prove disruption works, that the work of measuring it properly has not been done yet.

The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the Gambling Commission's Illegal Gambling Index calls itself "a robust and iterative measure", while its own methodology notes describe its website count as "not a complete count", its traffic estimates as "modelled estimates rather than directly observed", and apply a VPN uplift of 19 to 34% to cover a gap the document says "is not captured by this methodology". Second, the Commission's 9 November press release cites the dashboard as "further evidence to support enforcement activity and track progress in disrupting illegal markets", pointing to disruption figures (311 disruptions, a 77% traffic-reduction rate), while the dashboard's own text states that "disruption impact metrics are a developing area of work which will be strengthened as further work is undertaken". Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the Commission's underlying enforcement record, the accuracy of any specific disruption action, or the Illegal Gambling Index's technical methodology beyond what the dashboard itself discloses, none of which this piece independently tested. Both pages were fetched and verified live on 14 November 2026; the Commission's website returns HTTP 403 to a default scanner request but HTTP 200 to a standard browser request, bot-blocked rather than unreachable.

Sources

  1. Illegal gambling data dashboard - November 2026, Gambling Commission, published 5 November 2026
  2. Commission ramps up action against illegal gambling profits and assets, Gambling Commission, published 9 November 2026, last updated 9 November 2026
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail