TEARDOWN Published 20 November 2026 at 08:21. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The government found no national security risk in OCS's 3.1 billion pound takeover of Mitie on 21 October. Thirteen days earlier, the prisons minister had responded to a report calling one of Mitie's jails chaotic, unsafe and the site of a death in custody.

4 out of 5 stars4/53 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes

The Shard skyscraper in London, seen from Tower Hill, against a blue sky.
The Shard, London Bridge Street, Southwark, home to Mitie Group's head office on Level 12, photographed from Tower Hill, 30 November 2025. Photo: Acabashi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

In short. On 21 July 2026, Mitie's chairman told shareholders that OCS Group International's offer "recognises the strength of the business" and that our focus "stays firmly on delivering safely and reliably for our customers every day," in the words of Mitie's chief executive [[1]]. On 21 October 2026, the government's Investment Security Unit confirmed it would take no further action under the National Security and Investment Act, clearing the 3.1 billion pound deal's biggest regulatory hurdle [[2]]. Thirteen days earlier, the prisons minister had replied to the Ministry of Justice's own Independent Monitoring Board, whose first annual report on HMP Millsike, a prison run by Mitie Care & Custody, recorded that the jail "was not a safe place for prisoners and staff as soon as it was opened," that members "decided to visit in pairs for their own safety" for nearly the whole of the first year, and that one prisoner died in custody during the reporting period, in a death still under investigation [[4]]. Three documented mistakes: four stars.

OCS Group International Limited and Mitie Group plc announced their recommended merger on 21 July 2026: a cash offer valuing Mitie at approximately 3.1 billion pounds, creating what the companies called an "Enlarged Group" with combined revenues of roughly 8.5 billion pounds, "better placed to serve and safeguard some of the UK's most complex and critical built environments across government, defence, healthcare, national infrastructure and commercial markets" [[1]]. Mitie's chairman, Chris Rogers, said the offer "recognises the strength of the business, the progress achieved in recent years and the opportunities ahead," and would provide "a stronger platform for growth through greater scale, complementary capabilities and enhanced investment capacity" [[1]]. OCS's chief executive, Rob Legge, called it "a shared commitment to delivering the best outcomes for colleagues and customers" [[1]].

Two of the three regulatory conditions attached to the deal have now been satisfied. The European Commission cleared it under the EU Merger Regulation on 21 October 2026, and on the same day the Investment Security Unit notified OCS that no further action would be taken under the National Security and Investment Act 2021, the UK's screening regime for takeovers that touch critical infrastructure [[2]]. The third, a Competition and Markets Authority Phase 1 merger inquiry opened by commencement notice on 18 November 2026, remains open, with a statutory decision due by 20 January 2027 [[3]]. That inquiry tests market concentration. It does not test whether either company can safely deliver what it already runs.

The claims, tested

What the documents say What the evidence shows Verdict
Mitie's chief executive, Phil Bentley, 21 July 2026: our focus "stays firmly on delivering safely and reliably for our customers every day" [[1]], page 5 The Ministry of Justice's own Independent Monitoring Board, reporting on the same year, found HMP Millsike, a Mitie Care & Custody contract, "was not a safe place for prisoners and staff as soon as it was opened" [[4]], page 6, and that members "decided to visit in pairs for their own safety" for nearly the whole of the first year [[4]], page 11. One prisoner died in custody during the period, in a death still under investigation [[4]], page 12 "Safely and reliably" is the claim made to shareholders; the government's own evidence on a live Mitie contract says otherwise for most of the year it covers
Mitie's chairman, Chris Rogers, 21 July 2026: the offer reflects "the strength of the business, the progress achieved in recent years" and "a stronger platform for growth through greater scale" [[1]], page 4 The Board traces the unsafe opening directly to how this contract was run: the agreed 18-month mobilisation period "was subsequently reduced to 12 months" [[4]], page 5, leaving new officers "little opportunity to gain any experience in advance of the prison opening, which was shortened anyway" [[4]], page 5. The Board's own conclusion: the unsafe start "was obviously caused by the reduction of the mobilisation timescale" [[4]], page 6. In its comments appended to the minister's reply, Mitie describes the same compressed timetable as an achievement: the prison "was mobilised within 12 months rather than the 18 months originally envisaged" [[5]], page 4 The same fact, a shortened mobilisation period, is "progress" to shareholders and an achievement to the minister; the Board that watched it happen calls it the cause of an unsafe opening
OCS's chief executive, Rob Legge, 21 July 2026: the deal is "a shared commitment to delivering the best outcomes for colleagues and customers," building a group "better placed to serve and safeguard" critical infrastructure [[1]], pages 2 and 5 The staff Mitie already employs on a comparable government contract were themselves casualties of its instability: "the staff attrition rate was high throughout the year at all levels," with reasons including "officers not being paid and excessive unpredictable hours being worked" [[4]], page 5. The national security clearance that waved through a bigger version of this same company, on 21 October 2026, came 13 days after the minister had finished responding, on 8 October, to the Ministry's own report on exactly this contract [[5]], page 1 The screening process that tests ownership risk and the oversight process that tests delivery risk ran in parallel, on the government's own paper trail, without evident reference to each other

What the national security check actually checks

The National Security and Investment Act 2021 asks a narrow question: does a change of ownership create a risk that a hostile actor could exploit access to sensitive sectors. Mitie's HMP Millsike contract was not itself part of that screening; the Act looks at who controls an asset, not at how well it is being run. On that narrow question, the Investment Security Unit's "no further action" notice to OCS on 21 October 2026 is a reasonable, defensible answer [[2]]: there is no suggestion in any of the public documents that the ownership change itself creates an espionage or sabotage risk.

What the documents do not show is any sign that the national security screening, or the parallel European Commission clearance three weeks later, drew on what the Ministry of Justice already knew about Mitie Care & Custody's delivery record. The Independent Monitoring Board's report was published on 3 September 2026, six weeks before the Investment Security Unit's clearance. The minister's reply to it, acknowledging "one death in custody during the reporting period" and promising that "poor outcomes or lower standards are not accepted," was sent on 8 October, thirteen days before that clearance [[5]], page 1. Two arms of government were assessing different kinds of risk from the same company in the same autumn. Nothing in either document indicates they spoke to each other, and nothing in the Act requires that they should.

Credit where due

The Independent Monitoring Board's report is not a one-note account, and it would be unfair to read it as one. It records a genuine turnaround from February 2026, when a new interim director took over, paused new admissions, retrained staff "back to basics" on security and self-harm procedures, and introduced a more sustainable restricted regime [[4]], page 6. By the end of the reporting year, the Board records prisoner-on-staff assaults falling, self-harm levels converging with comparable category C prisons, and "a significant improvement in staff morale" [[4]], pages 6 to 8. The minister's reply is not complacent on its face either: it states plainly that "poor outcomes or lower standards are not accepted" during a new prison's early months, and HMPPS's own comments warn that "where poor performance persists, proportionate contractual action may be taken" [[5]], pages 1 and 3. And Mitie's account of its mobilisation programme is not simply self-praise: an independent Gateway Review by the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority rated it "Amber" and found the prison was "delivered to time and scope" [[5]], page 4, a genuinely external assessment, not just the company marking its own work.

None of that changes what the Board found on the ground for most of the year its report covers, or what its own words say caused it.

Three documented mistakes. (1) Mitie's chief executive told shareholders the company's focus "stays firmly on delivering safely and reliably," while the government's own monitors found a live Mitie contract unsafe for nearly the whole of the same year, with a death in custody under investigation. (2) Mitie's chairman and, separately, Mitie's own comments to the minister describe a mobilisation period cut from 18 months to 12 as a strength and an achievement; the Independent Monitoring Board's own conclusion is that this same decision caused the unsafe opening. (3) The national security clearance of a larger, combined Mitie, granted on 21 October 2026, came 13 days after the government had finished responding to its own report on Mitie's existing delivery problems, with no indication the two processes were connected. Rating: four stars.

Sources

  1. OCS Group International Limited and Mitie Group plc, "Recommended Cash Acquisition of Mitie Group plc by OCS Group International Limited" (Rule 2.7 Firm Offer Announcement), 21 July 2026
  2. Mitie Group plc, "Update on Regulatory Conditions" (RNS announcement confirming the UK National Security Condition satisfied), 22 October 2026
  3. Competition and Markets Authority, "OCS / Mitie merger inquiry" case page
  4. Independent Monitoring Board, annual report on HMP Millsike, 1 April 2025 to 30 April 2026, published 3 September 2026
  5. Ministry of Justice, ministerial response to the Independent Monitoring Board annual report on HMP Millsike, 8 October 2026
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail