A regime built to stop one tech failure from shaking Britain's financial system cannot fine the firms it designates. This month it added BlackRock, Bloomberg and three more, declaring the change will have no impact.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
In short. The Critical Third Parties (Designation) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, made 16 November and in force from 23 November, designate BlackRock, Bloomberg, Bottomline Technologies, Broadridge Financial Solutions and Form3 as critical third parties to the UK financial system [1]. The only legal basis for that designation is the Treasury's own opinion that a failure in these firms' services "could threaten the stability of, or confidence in, the UK financial system" [1]. The same instrument's Explanatory Note says no significant impact is foreseen [1], identical wording to the one that designated Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, Microsoft and Oracle in July [2]. Neither note mentions that the Act creating "critical third party" status gives regulators no power to fine one directly [5], unlike the standard penalty power the FCA holds over the firms it actually authorises [6]. Two documented omissions: four stars.
A critical third party is not a bank, an insurer or an investment firm. It is a company whose services sit underneath enough of them that if the company stops working, the sector it serves might stop working too. Parliament created the category in 2023 for exactly one reason: to let the Bank of England, the Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority watch the handful of firms the financial sector cannot function without, even though none of those firms is itself regulated as a bank [3]. On 16 November 2026 the Treasury used that power for the second time, adding five more names to a list that, until this year, held none [1].
The claims, tested
| The instrument's own words | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "In the Treasury's opinion, a failure in, or disruption to, the provision of services by the persons designated by these Regulations could threaten the stability of, or confidence in, the UK financial system" [1] | This finding, required by section 312L(2) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, is the sole legal test for designation [3]. The Explanatory Note to the same instrument says "a full impact assessment has not been produced for this instrument as no, or no significant, impact on the private, voluntary or public sector is foreseen" [1] - word for word the sentence that closed July's designation of Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, Microsoft and Oracle [2] | An instrument whose only legal basis is a finding of potential systemic harm closes with the boilerplate used for routine statutory instruments generally, regardless of which firm, or how large, is being brought in |
| Both Explanatory Notes describe who is designated and when, and say nothing else about what designation means for the firm concerned [1] [2] | The Act gives regulators a direction power, ordering a critical third party "to do anything specified in the direction, or refrain from doing anything specified in the direction" [4], and a power to prohibit or impose conditions on its service relationships with regulated firms if it breaches a requirement [5]. The FCA's ordinary financial penalty power, section 206, applies only "if the appropriate regulator considers that an authorised person has contravened a relevant requirement" or, under subsection (1A), a person subject to a Part 5A designated-activities requirement [6]; a critical third party is neither | Nothing in sections 312L to 312W creates a power to fine a critical third party. The strongest sanction on the books is cutting the firm off from the UK financial sector, a step no regulator has ever had to take |
What the status does not buy
Section 312R is the only enforcement tool built specifically for a critical third party that will not cooperate. It lets a regulator publish a notice stopping the firm providing services to regulated firms, stopping regulated firms receiving its services, or attaching conditions to either side of that relationship, once it is satisfied doing so "will not threaten the stability of, or confidence in, the UK financial system" [5]. That final condition is not a formality. The entire point of designating BlackRock, Bloomberg, Bottomline, Broadridge or Form3 is that their failure could already threaten that stability; a regulator reaching for the one sanction the Act gives it against them has to be satisfied that using it will not cause the very harm the designation exists to prevent. The direction power in section 312N is lighter-touch and more usable, letting a regulator tell a firm to do or stop doing something, with legal immunity attached if the direction is given to resolve a threat to financial stability [4]. Neither power includes a fine. The FCA, PRA and Bank of England between them have fined banks, insurers and individual bankers for two decades under section 206 [6]. None of that power extends to the companies this regime exists to watch.
A year of inertia, then two waves in five months
The Treasury Committee's report on AI in financial services, published 20 January 2026, is blunt about how long the regime sat unused. The regulators had published its detailed rules in November 2024, giving the Bank of England and the FCA "new powers of investigation and enforcement over firms which provide critical services to the UK financial services sector, including AI and cloud providers" [7]. A year on, no firm had been designated. After Amazon Web Services suffered a major cloud outage on 20 October 2025 that reached Lloyds Banking Group among others, the Committee asked the Economic Secretary to the Treasury why no major cloud or AI provider had been brought into the regime; the reply cited market sensitivities around naming candidates and said designations would follow in due course [7]. The Committee's recommendation was explicit: "By the end of 2026, HM Treasury must designate the major AI and cloud providers as critical third parties for the purposes of the Critical Third Parties Regime. Over a year since the regime was established, it is not clear to us why HM Treasury has been so slow to use the new powers at its disposal" [7].
Treasury met that deadline with months to spare. Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, Microsoft and Oracle became the first critical third parties on 13 July 2026, with the regulators describing a "new, proportionate regime, focused on the resilience of the critical services they provide to the UK financial sector" [8]. This month's instrument is the second wave, widening the list beyond cloud infrastructure into the financial sector's own back office: asset management, market data and payments software. The pace has picked up. What has not changed between July and November, or between the regime's creation in 2023 and today, is the enforcement toolkit available once a firm on that list is actually found wanting.
Credit where due
Treasury followed its own rules in full. Section 312L(4) requires consultation with the FCA, PRA and Bank of England, written notice to the firms being designated, and a chance for them to make representations before the instrument is made [3]; the instrument records all three steps as done [1]. The Treasury Committee's specific, dated demand, that the major AI and cloud providers be designated by the end of 2026, was met four months early, in July, not scraped in under the wire [7] [8]. And the underlying judgment behind the whole regime, that a handful of unregulated firms now sit close enough to the plumbing of UK finance to need watching, is not in dispute here; it is the same judgment this site's own reporting on bank-outage dependency risk keeps finding evidence for. The gap is not that Treasury moved slowly or acted in bad faith. It is that the paperwork accompanying two designation waves, in July and again this month, never once mentions that the power being exercised stops short of the one sanction regulators reach for most often elsewhere in financial services.
The star score counts two documented omissions, not misstatements: first, the November instrument's Explanatory Note repeats, unchanged, the same "no, or no significant, impact" boilerplate used for July's designation of four global cloud providers, despite the instrument's only legal basis being a finding that the designated firms' failure could threaten the stability of the entire UK financial system; second, neither the July nor the November Explanatory Note discloses that the enforcement powers the Act actually creates over a critical third party, a direction power and a power to prohibit or condition its services, stop short of the financial penalty power regulators hold over authorised firms under section 206. Two omissions in the 1-to-3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece takes no position on whether BlackRock, Bloomberg, Bottomline, Broadridge or Form3 pose any particular risk; it reports what the instrument designating them says, and what the Act creating that status actually allows a regulator to do about it. All eight sources below were fetched directly on 18 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200, except source 7, which returns HTTP 403 to automated requests (a known block on publications.parliament.uk's own HTML pages) and was independently verified live via the UK Parliament committees API (committees-api.parliament.uk) and a 21 October 2026 archived snapshot, both read in full before citing.
Sources
- The Critical Third Parties (Designation) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, made 16 November 2026, in force 23 November 2026
- The Critical Third Parties (Designation) Regulations 2026, made 8 July 2026, in force 13 July 2026
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 312L, Critical third parties: designation
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 312N, Directions
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 312R, Public censure
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 206, Financial penalties
- Artificial intelligence in financial services, Fifteenth Report of Session 2024-26 (HC 684), Treasury Committee, published 20 January 2026
- UK financial regulators to begin overseeing Critical Third Parties announced by Treasury, Financial Conduct Authority, published 10 July 2026