TEARDOWN Published 21 November 2026 at 05:32. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The CMA marked a year of its new consumer protection powers by opening three fresh cases against gyms and holiday firms. Each one's own small print says the investigation runs under the older law those new powers were meant to replace.

4 out of 5 stars4/53 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Aerial view of Blackpool North Pier extending into the sea, with the promenade and seafront visible alongside.
Blackpool North Pier and seafront, part of the UK's 103 million domestic holiday visits the CMA's own release cites. Photo: Mike McBey / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

In short. The Competition and Markets Authority's 18 November 2026 press release marks what it calls a year of its "major consumer protection drive" by naming three new drip-pricing investigations opened the day before: Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Leisure [[1]]. Each of the three case pages carries a personal-information notice stating that the CMA is collecting data "for its consumer protection investigation under Part 8 of the Enterprise Act 2002" [[2]][[3]][[4]], the older regime that requires a court to find an infringement, not the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA) powers the same release credits for letting the CMA "decide whether consumer law has been broken, rather than having to go through the courts" [[1]]. Two contemporary DMCCA cases checked for comparison, Wayfair and Trainline, both cite the DMCCA directly in the identical notice on their own case pages [[7]]. A second finding: the release's headline refund total, "£2.3 million", is lower than the "nearly £2.4 million" the CMA reported for what it describes as the same running tally five weeks earlier [[6]], a total that, with no case closures recorded in between, should only have grown. Three documented mistakes: four stars.

Travel and leisure businesses investigated over pricing practices was the CMA's chosen headline on 18 November 2026, timed to the day after the first anniversary of the launch this site has covered twice already: the 17 November 2025 opening of eight formal cases and 100 private advisory letters, and the £6 million of fines against three of those eight businesses that followed on 14 October 2026 [[6]][[8]]. The new release adds three more companies to the list, all in the same market sector as one of the first batch, Gold's Gym, which closed on 29 September 2026 with a £45,000 fine [[5]]. It also states a fresh set of headline numbers for the drive as a whole: 23 businesses investigated, "£2.3 million in refunds" and "more than £12 million" in fines since the DMCCA regime began in April 2025 [[1]]. Read against the three new cases' own published detail, both the legal basis and the arithmetic sit less neatly than the anniversary framing suggests.

The claims, tested

The CMA's own words What its own case pages and prior releases show Verdict
"Since April 2025, the CMA has been able to decide whether consumer law has been broken, rather than having to go through the courts under the DMCCA" (Emma Cochrane, Executive Director for Consumer Protection, 18 November 2026) [[1]] Each of the three cases named in the same release, Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Leisure, carries a personal-information notice stating the CMA is acting "for its consumer protection investigation under Part 8 of the Enterprise Act 2002" [[2]][[3]][[4]], the pre-DMCCA regime that requires a court finding. Wayfair and Trainline, two live DMCCA-era cases checked for comparison, instead cite "the consumer protection legislation which the CMA enforces (including the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024)" in the identical notice [[7]] The three cases used to illustrate a year of court-free enforcement are, on their own case pages' stated legal basis, not using it
"So far resulting in customers receiving £2.3 million in refunds and more than £12 million in fines being levied" since April 2025 (18 November 2026) [[1]] The CMA's own 14 October 2026 release states the same cumulative drive had by then "secured nearly £2.4 million in refunds for customers" over "the last 18 months" [[6]], a higher figure than the one reported five weeks later. No case closures or refund updates were published for this drive in the intervening period A running total that should only grow, if it changes at all, is lower in the regulator's own later statement of it than in its own earlier one
The release frames the three new cases as evidence the "crackdown" continues at its one-year mark, alongside citing 58 million overseas holidays, 103 million domestic visits and 11.5 million gym memberships as the scale at stake [[1]] Each of the three case pages logs the same single entry: "Initial investigation: information and evidence gathering (next case update April 2027)" [[2]][[3]][[4]]. The one directly comparable case, Gold's Gym, also in the recreation and leisure sector and over the same "mandatory fees not in the total price" allegation, took from 17 November 2025 to 29 September 2026, around ten and a half months, before any finding was published [[5]] On the regime's own published pace, nothing will be known about any of the three businesses named today for roughly five months, and a result on the Gold's Gym timetable would not be likely before next autumn

The mistakes, counted

Three cases presented as proof of a year of "new powers" are each, by their own published legal basis, proceeding under the old ones (1). The DMCCA's distinct selling point, as the CMA's own executive director states it in this release, is that the regulator can "decide whether consumer law has been broken" itself, without going "through the courts" [[1]]. Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Leisure were opened the day before this release and named in it as the drive's latest instalment [[1]]. Each one's personal-information notice, a required part of every CMA case page, states plainly that the investigation is being carried out "under Part 8 of the Enterprise Act 2002" [[2]][[3]][[4]], the regime DMCCA was built to move cases away from. Checked against two other live cases from the same drive, Wayfair (fined under DMCCA on 14 October 2026) and Trainline (opened 18 August 2026, still open), both case pages instead name "the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024" directly in the same notice [[7]]. The three businesses chosen to mark the DMCCA's anniversary are the ones whose own paperwork does not claim to be using it.

The headline refund figure for the drive's lifetime has gone down since the regulator's own last count of it (2). On 14 October 2026 the CMA stated it had "secured nearly £2.4 million in refunds for customers" over "the last 18 months" of the drive [[6]]. On 18 November 2026, five weeks later, the same cumulative figure, covering the same period since the DMCCA came into force, is given as "£2.3 million" [[1]]. No case closures, settlements or refund updates for this drive were published by the CMA in the intervening five weeks, as far as the public record shows. A running total built from fines and refunds already paid does not fall on its own; the CMA's two statements of its own number do not agree, and neither release explains the difference.

The three new cases are offered as evidence a "crackdown" is continuing, while their own timetables promise nothing for five months (3). All three case pages carry an identical entry: "Initial investigation: information and evidence gathering (next case update April 2027)" [[2]][[3]][[4]]. The release pairs this with large scale-setting figures, 58 million overseas holidays, 103 million domestic visits, 11.5 million gym memberships, to frame the announcement as significant news today [[1]]. The one case in the same sector, over the same allegation, that has actually finished, Gold's Gym, took close to eleven months from opening to its Final Infringement Notice [[5]]. On that precedent, a reader told today that the CMA is cracking down on hidden gym and holiday fees will not learn whether any of the three named businesses did anything wrong until deep into next year, if then.

Credit where due

The release is specific, not vague, about what each of the three businesses is accused of: Bannatyne over joining fees "added later in the purchasing process", Secret Escapes over ATOL fees, local taxes, resort fees and flight-price accuracy, Caledonian over per-person pricing and mandatory fees in package holidays [[1]][[2]][[3]][[4]]. All three case pages state, in the same words used for every CMA investigation at this stage, that "it should not be assumed" the named business "has infringed consumer protection law and no finding has been made" [[2]][[3]][[4]]. The £45,000 Gold's Gym penalty and its 40 per cent settlement reduction, the figures this piece uses as the sector's working precedent, were disclosed by the CMA itself in full, not extracted under challenge [[5]][[6]].

Verdict

Four stars, from three documented mistakes. The CMA's underlying complaint, that gyms and holiday firms keep adding fees after the headline price, is well evidenced and specific in all three new cases. What the anniversary framing does not survive is its own small print: the cases chosen to showcase a year of DMCCA enforcement cite the older Enterprise Act regime, the refund total has moved in the wrong direction since the regulator's last count of it, and the only comparable finished case puts a result on these three businesses the better part of a year away.

The star score counts three documented mistakes. First, the three cases named to mark a year of the DMCCA drive, Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Leisure, each cite "Part 8 of the Enterprise Act 2002" as their legal basis in their own case-page notice, not the DMCCA powers the same release credits with letting the CMA decide cases without going to court; two comparison DMCCA cases, Wayfair and Trainline, cite the DMCCA directly in the identical notice. Second, the release's "£2.3 million" cumulative refund figure is lower than the "nearly £2.4 million" the CMA itself reported for the same running total five weeks earlier, with no case closures published in between to explain the fall. Third, the three new cases are presented as evidence of a continuing crackdown while their own timetables promise no further update before April 2027, and the one comparable finished case in the same sector took around ten and a half months to reach a result. Three falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the competence of any named individual; the drafting of these releases and case pages is institutional, not any one official's decision. Checked directly against the CMA's press releases and case pages cited, fetched 21 November 2026.

Sources

  1. Travel and leisure businesses investigated over pricing practices, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, published 18 November 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  2. Bannatyne Health Club: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, published 18 November 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  3. Secret Escapes Limited: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, published 18 November 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  4. Caledonian Leisure Ltd trading as Caledonian Travel: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, published 18 November 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  5. Gold's Gym (UK) Limited: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, last updated 14 October 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  6. CMA fines firms £6 million for misleading sales tactics, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, published 14 October 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  7. Wayfair: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, last updated 14 October 2026, checked 21 November 2026; Trainline: consumer protection enforcement case, GOV.UK / Competition and Markets Authority, last updated 18 August 2026, checked 21 November 2026.
  8. "The CMA fined three firms £6 million this week, calling it proof its new consumer protection powers work. One of the eight businesses named in the same drive last year is still open, weeks past its own promised update.", Tracked Changes, 15 October 2026.
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail