Ofgem found eleven pension schemes behind energy bills are now in surplus, up from five three years ago. It says consumers should share that benefit, then proposes no change and defers any plan to 2029.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. On 30 October 2026 Ofgem published its triennial notice on pension allowances for RIIO network operators, the costs of defined benefit schemes that these companies recover through regulated revenue [1]. Its own figures show those schemes hold a defined benefit obligation of 25.6 billion pounds against 26.1 billion pounds in assets, a 0.5 billion pound aggregate surplus, with eleven schemes individually in surplus against five at the 2023 review (page 2) [1]. Ofgem states that "consumers should benefit from resulting surpluses to the extent that they have borne the associated funding burden and risk" (page 4) [1]. Its provisional decision is "no changes to the base Pension Scheme Established Deficit (PSED) values" and no adjustment factor on any operator's allowance (page 2) [1]; the only step tied to consumer benefit is a non-binding recommendation that operators "maintain a documented strategy" for surplus use, to be checked at the next review in 2029 (page 5) [1]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Ofgem runs this review every three years because consumers, not shareholders, have historically carried the cost when network operators' pension schemes fall short. The notice is explicit about why that matters now: "consumers have historically borne the funding burden of established pension deficits through allowed revenues" (page 4) [1]. What has changed since the 2023 review is the direction of travel. Funding positions have "generally improved," with eleven schemes now reporting a surplus at their most recent valuation against five previously, six of them funded between 100 and 105 percent and one, the Scottish Hydro-Electric Pension Scheme, at 120 percent (page 3) [1]. Across all the schemes Ofgem monitors, the networks now report a combined 0.5 billion pound surplus, 26.1 billion pounds in assets against a 25.6 billion pound obligation (page 2, footnote 3) [1].
A principle with no trigger
Ofgem states its own test for what should happen next in plain terms. It calls this "symmetry between risk, funding and reward": because consumers funded the deficits, they should get a "commensurate share of the benefit from any resulting surplus" (page 1 and page 4) [1]. It goes further, setting out that "consumers should not fund deficits under one sharing arrangement only for surplus value arising from the same liabilities to be distributed on a materially different basis" (page 5) [1]. That is a direct statement of fairness, not a hedge.
The next sentence removes the trigger that would make it operate. Ofgem's own notice says: "the existence of a pension scheme surplus does not, in itself, demonstrate that consumers have overpaid or that an immediate adjustment is appropriate" (page 5) [1]. Taken together, the two statements leave the symmetry principle with no operative test: a surplus funded partly by consumers does not, on its own, entitle them to anything, and the notice does not say what, short of that, would. The document itself records that some schemes are already using their surpluses for "contribution holidays, reduced employer contributions or expense reserves," and says only that "Ofgem should be satisfied that consumers receive an appropriate share of the benefit" where that happens, "particularly where surpluses have arisen partly from historic consumer-funded deficit contributions" (page 2) [1]. "Should be satisfied" is not a test with a number attached, and the notice does not say how or when Ofgem will check.
The actual decision changes nothing
Strip away the principle and the actual provisional decision in this review is narrow. Ofgem proposes "no changes to the base Pension Scheme Established Deficit (PSED) values and PPH submitted by NWOs," and "does not consider that an adjustment factor should be applied to any NWO's pension allowance" (page 2) [1]. The revised allowance values in the notice's own appendices are, by its account, "broadly consistent with that determined following the 2023 reasonableness review" (page 1) [1].
The one step that touches the surplus question directly is a set of seven "provisional recommendations to network operators," and every one of them is a request for documentation, not a requirement to act. The first asks operators to "maintain a documented strategy for the use of current and emerging surpluses," covering "the expected timing and value of benefits, and how those benefits will be shared with existing and future consumers" (page 5) [1]. The seventh asks only that, "for the 2029 review," operators provide "a clear reconciliation" of what happened to the surplus since 2026 (page 6) [1]. Ofgem itself is explicit that none of this binds anyone: the symmetry principles "do not predetermine the outcome for any individual scheme or proposal" (page 5) [1]. Three years pass between the finding that consumers may be owed a share of a growing surplus and the next point at which Ofgem has committed to even look again. Representations on the provisional figures are due by 5pm on 13 November 2026, after which Ofgem expects to publish its final decision, with the revised allowances taking effect from 1 April 2027 (page 6) [1] [2].
The claims, tested
| Ofgem's own words | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "Consumers should benefit from resulting surpluses to the extent that they have borne the associated funding burden and risk" (page 4) [1] | The same notice says a surplus "does not, in itself, demonstrate that consumers have overpaid or that an immediate adjustment is appropriate" (page 5) [1] | The fairness principle has no stated trigger for when it applies |
| Eleven schemes are now in surplus against five at the 2023 review, a combined 0.5 billion pound surplus across all monitored schemes (pages 2 and 3) [1] | The provisional decision is "no changes" to allowances, and the only consumer-facing step is a non-binding documentation recommendation checked next at the 2029 review (pages 2 and 5) [1] | A proven, growing surplus produces a request for paperwork, not a date by which consumers see anything back |
Credit where due
Ofgem is not hiding either gap. Both the symmetry principle and the sentence that empties it of an automatic trigger appear in the same section of the same document, not buried in an annex a reader would have to find. The notice also discloses, in its own numbers, exactly how much is at stake, 25.6 billion pounds in obligations against 26.1 billion pounds in assets, rather than describing the surplus only in general terms. And it is honest about the limits of its own analysis: it says the Government Actuary's Department was "generally satisfied" with how operators have considered consumer interests so far, without overstating that satisfaction into a finding that consumers have already been treated fairly on the surplus question specifically. Ofgem is also keeping the door open to a harder rule later, noting that "the increasing prevalence of pension scheme surpluses may raise broader questions about whether the existing pensions funding framework continues to allocate risks and benefits appropriately" (page 5) [1], even though it attaches no timetable to that work either.
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. Ofgem has proven, in its own figures, that the schemes funded through energy bills now hold a bigger and more widespread surplus than three years ago, and it has stated a fairness principle that says consumers are owed a share of that growth. It has then written a sentence that removes the trigger for applying the principle, and backed the whole question with nothing firmer than a request that companies write down a strategy, checked again only once, in 2029. Anyone paying a network charge on their energy bill this winter is funding schemes that, on Ofgem's own account, are in a stronger position than they were three years ago, with no date attached to when, or whether, any of that improvement reaches them.
The star score counts two documented mistakes: Ofgem's notice states a "symmetry" principle that consumers who funded historic pension deficits "should benefit" from resulting surpluses, then states in the same document that a surplus "does not, in itself, demonstrate that consumers have overpaid or that an immediate adjustment is appropriate," leaving the principle with no stated test for when it actually applies; and despite its own figures showing eleven of the monitored schemes now in surplus against five at the 2023 review, with a combined 0.5 billion pound surplus, the review's provisional decision is no change to allowances, with consumer benefit addressed only through a non-binding recommendation that operators document their surplus strategy, not checked again until the 2029 review. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding that Ofgem's funding methodology or GAD's actuarial assessment is wrong; nothing here disputes that the changes GAD reviewed were, in its words, free of major concerns. The finding is narrower: a stated fairness principle and a proven, growing surplus are both in the regulator's own document, and neither is matched with an operative mechanism or date. Checked directly against Ofgem's Notice of provisional revised pension allowance values and 2026 reasonableness review (full text, published 30 October 2026) and its case landing page, both fetched 11 November 2026.
Sources
- Notice of our provisional revised pension allowance values for RIIO network operators and 2026 reasonableness review (PDF), Ofgem, 30 October 2026
- Notice of our provisional revised pension allowance values and 2026 reasonableness review, Ofgem, policy landing page