TEARDOWN Published 12 November 2026 at 08:14. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

HSE's own data finds asbestos contractors appointing their own clearance checker in 53 percent of cases, the exact conflict its rules have warned against for 20 years. The fix for it does not take effect until November 2027.

4 out of 5 stars4/53 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Redgrave Court, a modern glass and brick office building in Bootle, Merseyside, the headquarters of the Health and Safety Executive.
Redgrave Court, Bootle, Merseyside, headquarters of the Health and Safety Executive. Photo: Bill Boaden / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In short. On 3 November 2026 the Health and Safety Executive published its response to a consultation on the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012, confirming it will stop a contractor removing asbestos from also appointing the person who checks the site is safe to reoccupy [1]. HSE's own notification data, collected since June 2024, finds the contractor makes that appointment in 53 percent of cases, the exact arrangement its safety guidance has warned against for nearly 20 years (page 10) [1]. The legal fix for it, regulation 2(2) of the resulting Statutory Instrument, does not come into force until 25 November 2027, a year after the rest of the regulations, and the instrument's own Explanatory Note confirms the old practice "continue[s] to apply" until that date [3]. HSE's own press release announcing the change states twice that its regulations come into force on 24 November 2026, a day earlier than the instrument itself says [2] [3]. Three documented mistakes: four stars.

Asbestos is still, in HSE's own words, the single biggest cause of workplace death in Britain, killing around 5,000 people a year, more than die on the roads [4]. When a licensed contractor finishes removing it from a building, the law requires a separate, final check, the four-stage clearance process, ending in a site clearance certificate confirming the area is safe to reoccupy [1]. HSE's consultation response, published after 358 responses to a question it put to industry between 10 November 2025 and 9 January 2026, deals with who is allowed to appoint the person doing that final check [1].

A conflict of interest HSE has measured, not guessed at

The document is specific about how long this has been a known problem and how often it actually happens. "This recommendation has been stated in the Approved Code of Practice (ACoP) supporting CAR 2012 for nearly 20 years (first edition in 2006 and second edition 2012)" (page 10) [1]. That recommendation was never binding, only advised. "Since June 2024, HSE has collected information from notifications for work with asbestos (via the ASB5 form) about who appoints the analyst. In 53% of cases the licensed asbestos removal contractor (LARC) appoints the analyst, and in 46% of situations the client appoints the analyst" (page 10) [1]. HSE draws the conclusion plainly: "Client/dutyholders have had time to understand and comply with this recommendation through a non-regulatory approach and yet HSE data shows there continues to be a lack of independence and impartially when appointing the analyst in just over half of licensable removal works" (page 10) [1]. The reason this matters to HSE is not administrative tidiness: it "views the lack of independence and impartiality in the 4SC process as a potential risk of exposure to asbestos" (page 17) [1]. A contractor checking its own work is, on HSE's own data, the normal state of affairs in more than half of licensable asbestos removal jobs in Great Britain.

The fix for a known risk takes a year to start working

HSE's response states that it "will use the consultation findings to develop a Statutory Instrument to amend regulation 20... to ensure independence and impartiality in the 4SC process, and to remove the potential conflicts of interest that may arise when the LARC appoints the asbestos analyst" (page 17) [1], adding that "the majority of responses suggest a transitional period of 12 months would be sufficient time" (page 17) [1].

That Statutory Instrument, the Control of Asbestos (Amendment etc.) Regulations 2026, was made on 2 November 2026. Its substituted regulation 20 adds a new rule: "A person cannot be appointed to carry out an assessment under paragraph (3) by the employer who was required to ensure the premises or parts of premises were thoroughly cleaned" [3]. But the instrument's own commencement clause splits the start date in two: "these Regulations come into force on 25th November 2026", except that "Regulation 2(2) comes into force on 25th November 2027" [3], regulation 2(2) being the substituted regulation 20 that contains the independence rule itself. The Explanatory Note removes any doubt about what that means in practice: "the requirements in the 2012 Regulations prior to their amendment by regulation 2(2) continue to apply until 25th November 2027... the employer who carried out the work relating to asbestos on premises can continue to appoint another person to assess the cleanliness of those premises until that date" [3]. By the time that date arrives, HSE will have been sitting on more than three years of its own ASB5 data confirming the exact conflict of interest in a majority of cases, without the power to stop it.

The department's own press release gets its own date wrong

HSE's press release announcing all this states that "the Statutory Instrument in parliament to amend the regulations... will come into force on 24 November 2026, with industry having a year to comply before HSE enforces the change in November 2027" [2], and repeats in its notes to editors that "the Statutory Instrument will come into force on 24 November 2026" [2]. The instrument itself, read directly, says 25 November 2026 [3]. It is a one-day error about the department's own regulations, in the department's own announcement of them, checkable by reading the two documents side by side.

No impact assessment, against the consultation's own numbers

The Statutory Instrument carries no impact assessment. Its Explanatory Note states: "A full impact assessment has not been produced for this instrument as no, or no significant, impact on the private or voluntary sector is foreseen" [3]. HSE's own consultation response describes a different picture. Asked directly about further costs, "85% (304) of respondents answered this question with 69% (209) suggesting there would be no additional costs, and 31% (95) suggesting there would be additional costs" (page 16), split between "increased administrative and procurement costs" and "delays, rework, and programme disruption costs" (page 16) [1]. On the impact for licensed removal contractors specifically, "33% (107) foreseeing a low impact, 31% (99) a medium impact and 19% a high impact. 10% (33) suggested no impact" (page 12) [1]. Almost a third of respondents flagging additional costs, and fewer than one in ten of the directly affected contractors expecting no impact at all, is not the profile of a change with no significant impact foreseen.

Credit where due

HSE ran a substantial consultation, not a token one: 358 responses, broken down by business size and region, with specific questions testing its own cost estimates rather than assuming them. The 12-month transition period it settled on was not picked from nowhere; it reflects what the largest single group of respondents, 32 percent, actually asked for (page 11) [1]. HSE also did not hide the delay: the press release states the November 2027 enforcement date plainly, in the open, rather than burying it. The underlying data collection, two and a half years of ASB5 notifications used to measure a problem rather than assume it, is the kind of evidence this site generally wants to see more of.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the record shows Verdict
HSE will amend regulation 20 "to remove the potential conflicts of interest that may arise when the LARC appoints the asbestos analyst" (page 17) [1] The Statutory Instrument's own commencement clause delays the substituted regulation 20 until 25 November 2027, and its Explanatory Note confirms the old practice "continue[s] to apply" until then [3] The conflict HSE's own data finds in 53 percent of cases stays legal for another year
The regulations "will come into force on 24 November 2026" (press release, stated twice) [2] The instrument itself gives 25 November 2026 as the general commencement date [3] A one-day factual error in the department's own announcement of its own regulations
"No, or no significant, impact on the private or voluntary sector is foreseen", so no impact assessment was produced [3] HSE's own consultation found 31% of respondents expecting additional costs and only 10% of licensed removal contractors expecting no impact at all (pages 12 and 16) [1] The no-significant-impact finding sits against the department's own survey data

Verdict

Four stars, from three documented mistakes. None of them is a claim that HSE is wrong to act, or that the new independence rule is a bad idea; the consultation response and the rule it produced both rest on real measurement of a real problem. The findings are narrower: the fix for a conflict of interest HSE's own data finds in a majority of licensable removal jobs will not be enforceable for another year, the department's own press release misstates the date its regulations start, and the instrument waives an impact assessment on grounds its own consultation data does not clearly support. Asbestos removal is not a paperwork exercise; the clearance certificate is the document that tells people a room is safe to walk back into.

The star score counts three documented mistakes: first, the Statutory Instrument's substituted regulation 20, the provision stopping a contractor appointing its own site clearance checker, does not come into force until 25 November 2027, a year after the rest of the regulations, during which the Explanatory Note confirms the pre-amendment rule "continue[s] to apply"; second, HSE's own press release states twice that the regulations come into force on 24 November 2026, a day earlier than the instrument itself; third, the instrument's Explanatory Note states no impact assessment was produced because no significant impact is foreseen, against HSE's own consultation finding that 31% of respondents expected additional costs and only 10% of licensed removal contractors expected no impact. Three falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding that HSE's underlying policy is wrong, or that any named official acted improperly; the drafting and announcement of a Statutory Instrument is an institutional process. Checked directly against HSE's consultation response (40 pages, published 3 November 2026), HSE's press release, the Control of Asbestos (Amendment etc.) Regulations 2026 as made, and HSE's own asbestos guidance page, all fetched 12 November 2026.

Sources

  1. HSE response to consultation on legislative and guidance proposals for the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 (PDF), Health and Safety Executive, published 3 November 2026
  2. HSE takes action to strengthen asbestos safety standards following consultation, HSE press release, 3 November 2026
  3. The Control of Asbestos (Amendment etc.) Regulations 2026, legislation.gov.uk, made 2 November 2026
  4. Why is asbestos dangerous?, Health and Safety Executive
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail