The government promises genuine pensions for all private sector workers through a new pooled scheme. Its own response admits not everyone gets access at launch, and the pot size the scheme needs to work is still unresolved.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
In short. On 3 November 2026, DWP published its response to the public consultation on Retirement Collective Pension Schemes (RCPS), the pooled-risk vehicle meant to give defined contribution savers "an income that is designed to last for life" [1]. The same day's press release promised the government is "resurrecting the option of genuine pensions for all private sector workers" [3]. The response's own paragraph 3.4 says the opposite of "all": "not all pension savers will have access to RCPS when they are first introduced" [1]. The ministerial foreword also promises RCPS "target inflation-adjusted increases, helping members maintain their purchasing power over time" [1], but the draft regulations published alongside it drop the one rule that would guarantee it, reopening as a question whether new cohorts should have to target inflation at all [2]. And the pot size the scheme needs to work is left unset, referred to a different consultation that, on inspection, asks a different question [1]. Three documented mistakes: four stars.
Torsten Bell, the Minister for Pensions, opens the response with a promise that reads like a correction of history. "The 2010s saw a transformation of workplace pension saving via automatic enrolment," he writes. "We now have an opportunity to ensure that the retirement phase evolves as well" [1]. Retirement Collective Pension Schemes, he says, will let defined contribution savers draw "a regular income, protection against longevity risk, the prospect of maintaining living standards over time and freedom from the burden of managing investments" [1]. It is a genuinely large reform, covering a defined contribution savings base counted in the tens of millions. It is also a response document that, in its own paragraphs, walks back three pieces of that promise before the ink is dry.
A policy announced twice, with two different scopes
The press release announcing this response leaves no room for qualification. "The Government is now acting to resurrect the option of genuine pensions for all private sector workers," it says, with Torsten Bell quoted promising to be "guaranteeing them the option of an income that last throughout retirement" [3].
The response itself is more careful, because its own design will not deliver that. Access to RCPS runs through exactly one route: "our intention remains that initially, Guided Retirement will be the only route through which members access RCPS," and a trustee or scheme operator, not the individual saver, decides whether to offer it at all (para 3.4) [1]. The same paragraph states the consequence plainly: "we recognise that this means not all pension savers will have access to RCPS when they are first introduced, however, this may be mitigated through common adoption by schemes under Guided Retirement" (para 3.4) [1]. "May be mitigated" is not a date, and "common adoption" is not a requirement; it describes a hope about market behaviour, not a commitment the document makes to deliver.
The timing gap is not hypothetical. Respondents to the original consultation warned that "the timings needed to be changed so that RCPS can become operational before Guided Retirement solutions need to be selected and implemented" (para 3.3) [1], raising the prospect that trustees could be required to choose a default pension for their members before the pooled-risk option exists to choose. The response does not give a date by which RCPS will be ready, nor a date by which access will stop depending on which employer a saver happens to have.
A purchasing-power promise dropped the same day it was made
The ministerial foreword's claim that RCPS "target inflation-adjusted increases, helping members maintain their purchasing power over time" [1] describes "cohorting", the mechanism by which RCPS schemes open a new group of members periodically so that a well-performing scheme's existing pensioners are not forced to subsidise newcomers joining after a market fall. Each cohort "aspire[s] to provide a certain level of annual adjustments," but "different cohorts will have different adjustments due to historic performance" (draft regulations, para 3.12) [2].
The draft regulations consultation, published the same day as the response carrying that foreword, says the one number that would make "purchasing power" a guarantee rather than an aspiration has been dropped: "in the RCPS policy consultation, we proposed that the cohorts should target at least CPI. This enforces the first gateway test by requiring the scheme, with each new cohort, to target CPI. This requirement is absent from the draft regulations, and we would appreciate views, in conjunction with question 5, as to whether cohorts being required to target at least CPI is appropriate, or whether a more permissive approach should be taken" (para 3.13) [2]. A rule the government itself had proposed, that would have obliged every new cohort to at least aim for inflation, is gone from the regulations that would enact it, replaced by an open question about whether to require anything at all. The consultation asking that question is open now and closes on 15 December 2026 [2].
The pot size that decides whether this works for anyone, left for someone else to answer
RCPS only pools risk if enough money is in the pool. The response's own consultees were specific about the floor: "a small number of respondents suggested the minimum pot size should be in the £20,000 to £30,000 range. However, some responses suggested that average pot size within the scheme would need to be higher, around £100,000" (para 2.28) [1].
The government's answer is to set no floor at all, and to point elsewhere: "we do not intend to prescribe a minimum pot size for RCPS in draft regulations. The government has published a consultation on Guided Retirement policy which is seeking views on the minimum viable pot size for providing a regular income in retirement, (please see chapter 3 of that consultation), and we encourage stakeholders to provide further views through the Guided Retirement policy consultation" (para 2.32) [1]. Chapter 3 of the Guided Retirement consultation does ask a pot-size question, but it is a different one: Question 9 asks "what is the lowest pot value under which it would be commercially viable to provide protection against longevity risk," a general test for any form of longevity protection, not a figure for what an RCPS specifically needs to hold [4]. That same chapter is also where the £10,000 threshold for the separate longevity-protection duty sits, a threshold its own Figure 1 shows excludes 820,000 people aged 55 to 59 and 620,000 aged 60 to 65, 1.44 million people, from mandatory protection on their smallest pot alone (para 3.12-3.13) [4]. Nobody in either document has yet said whether those 1.44 million people, sitting below £10,000, are anywhere near the £20,000 to £100,000 range the RCPS response's own consultees say the scheme needs to be viable for them.
The claims, tested
| The claim | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "Resurrecting the option of genuine pensions for all private sector workers" [3] | The response's own para 3.4 says access runs only through trustees choosing to adopt RCPS under Guided Retirement, and "not all pension savers will have access to RCPS when they are first introduced" [1] | "All" in the press release becomes "not all" in the document it is announcing |
| RCPS "target inflation-adjusted increases, helping members maintain their purchasing power over time" (foreword) [1] | The proposed CPI floor for new cohorts is "absent from the draft regulations", reopened as a question the same day [2] | The one rule that would enforce the promise is not in the rules |
| No minimum pot size needed; the question is being asked (para 2.32) [1] | The consultation it points to asks about longevity protection generally, not RCPS viability; its own consultees suggest £20,000-£100,000 against an existing £10,000 statutory threshold that already excludes 1.44 million people [4] | The number that decides who this scheme is for has not been answered anywhere |
The mistakes, counted
A universal promise with a non-universal document (1). The press release says "for all private sector workers" [3]; the response it announces says "not all pension savers will have access to RCPS when they are first introduced" (para 3.4) [1], with no date fixed for when that stops being true.
An inflation promise with no inflation rule (2). The foreword's "purchasing power" commitment [1] rests on cohorting, and the one mechanism that would have made it a floor rather than an aspiration, a required CPI target for each new cohort, was proposed by the government itself and then dropped from the draft regulations published the same day (para 3.13) [2].
A viability number asked in the wrong document (3). The response declines to set a minimum pot size and sends stakeholders to Question 9 of the Guided Retirement consultation (para 2.32) [1], which asks about commercial viability of longevity protection in general, not the £20,000 to £100,000 range its own consultees named for RCPS specifically (para 2.28) [1], while the £10,000 threshold already fixed into law by the sibling Guided Retirement duty leaves 1.44 million people below it [4].
Credit where due
The response does not dodge the hard questions; it answers some of them with real caution rather than convenient silence. Respondents asked for permission to let well-performing cohorts absorb cuts gradually over a scheme's whole lifetime rather than facing an immediate reduction once pensions pass an upper threshold; the government turned that down, stating plainly that it would "not be pursuing the removal of the upper threshold and allowing the spreading of cuts over the lifetime of the scheme at this time" [2], a more protective choice than some respondents wanted. A 0.75% annual charge cap on the collective fund is introduced where no decumulation product in the market currently has one [1]. Members who find RCPS does not suit them get a one-year window to convert to flexi-access drawdown instead [1]. And the consultation that produced this response drew 56 substantive responses, with the government's summary of each question's feedback printed alongside its answer, not just the answer alone.
Verdict
Four stars, from three documented mistakes. The policy idea, pooling longevity risk so savers get an income rather than a dwindling pot, answers a real problem the response itself documents in detail. What is missing is the follow-through: a press release that says "all" when the document says "not all", a purchasing-power promise resting on a rule the same day's draft regulations quietly drop, and a viability number that two consultations each assume the other has already settled. A scheme meant to replace guesswork with a guarantee should not itself be built on three unresolved blanks.
Sources
- Government response to the public consultation on Retirement Collective Pension Schemes, Department for Work and Pensions, 3 November 2026.
- The Pension Schemes (Retirement Collective Money Purchase Schemes) (Amendment) Regulations 2027: consultation, Department for Work and Pensions, 3 November 2026 (open, closes 15 December 2026).
- "New plans 'resurrect' genuine pensions for millions of private sector workers", Department for Work and Pensions press release, 3 November 2026.
- Guided retirement: policy consultation, Department for Work and Pensions, HM Treasury, Financial Conduct Authority and The Pensions Regulator, 3 November 2026.