Water bosses blocked from a bonus for polluting rivers are drawing the same money anyway, through payments the rule's own definition leaves out. Ofwat admits the gap, then leaves the fix for a later, unscheduled consultation.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. Ofwat's ban on performance-related bonuses for water company bosses has blocked more than £10 million since it took effect, including £6.5 million from nine companies that triggered it in 2025-26 alone [1]. The same day those figures were published, Ofwat's own call for evidence admitted that several companies responded to the ban by creating new "retention payments" that sit "outside the scope of the rule and its definition of performance related pay," with some individual director schemes "totalling over £1 million over a five-year period" and base salary rises "of more than 20%" [2]. Closing that gap is left to "a later date" in Ofwat's own review, with no date attached, even though the same document says the Water Industry Act 1991 already gives Ofwat the power to set wider remuneration rules without waiting for new legislation [2]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
On 12 November, the Environment Secretary announced a review of her own government's water company bonus ban, nine months after a white paper credited that same ban as something already finished. "We banned unfair executive bonuses and made pollution cover-ups a criminal offence," the white paper states, listing it alongside £104 billion of secured private investment as one of the government's delivered achievements [3]. Ofwat, the regulator that actually administers the ban, used 12 November to publish the detail behind why that sentence does not settle the matter: a call for evidence into how water companies have been working around the rule since shortly after it took effect [2].
A ban already worked around
The Water (Special Measures) Act 2025 gave Ofwat new rule-making powers to prohibit performance-related pay (PRP) for water company executives in certain circumstances; Ofwat introduced its PRP Prohibition Rule in June 2025 [2]. Almost every incumbent water and sewerage company bar one, Hafren Dyfrdwy, has triggered it at least once, mostly over Category 1 pollution incidents or breaches of the statutory duty to provide a sewerage system; five companies triggered it in both years it has applied [2]. The rule has, on its own terms, worked as a blocking mechanism: a combined £10 million in potential CEO and CFO bonuses prohibited across two years, £6.5 million of that in 2025-26 from nine companies [1].
What happened next is in Ofwat's own words, not an outside critic's: "several water companies began to change their remuneration policies soon after the rule was implemented. Some created new non-performance related so-called 'retention payments' which were outside the scope of the rule and its definition of performance related pay. Other companies chose to increase base salaries of their executive directors significantly above historic norms or what was paid to other staff" [2]. The scale is not trivial: "some schemes for an individual director totalling over £1 million over a five-year period," and base pay rises "of more than 20%" [2]. Ofwat's verdict on its own rule: these decisions "may have given the impression that many companies who had triggered the rule were undermining it by replacing PRP that was prohibited with fixed, non-performance related pay" [2].
The fix has no date either
The Environment Secretary, Dame Angela Eagle, framed the response as a matter of political will: "People are sick of seeing water bosses profit while rivers are polluted and customers are repeatedly let down. A wide-ranging review launching today will ensure that failure doesn't pay, whatever name the payment goes by. The bonus ban was the first step. Where there are loopholes, I want them closed" [1]. The press release points to two routes: Ofwat's four-week call for evidence, closing 10 December, and, separately, "the government's work to strengthen accountability in the water sector, including through the strengthened Water Bill" [1]. Neither route carries a date for an actual rule change. Ofwat's own document is explicit about the first: "changes to specific elements of the rule will be considered in our review at a later date which will be subject to consultation" [2]. The Water Bill referenced in the press release has no timetable attached either.
What the press release does not mention is that Ofwat says it may not need either the call for evidence or the Bill to close this specific gap. Its own document states: "the Water Industry Act 1991 does provide Ofwat with powers to set wider rules on remuneration," and goes on to float a concrete option under that existing power: "this could include prohibiting 'retention payments' when a standard of the PRP rule has been triggered or requiring such payments meet certain criteria to qualify as a genuine retention mechanism, rather than used to replace PRP that has been prohibited" [2]. That is a tool Ofwat already holds, named in its own paperwork, that the press release skips past in favour of pointing at a future law.
The claims, tested
| The document's own words | What the evidence shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| The government's white paper, February 2026: "We banned unfair executive bonuses" [3], listed among completed achievements | Ofwat's November 2026 call for evidence says several companies have been routing around the ban since shortly after it took effect, via "retention payments" outside the rule's own definition and base pay rises of more than 20%, with individual schemes exceeding £1 million over five years [2] | Unmatched: the ban is contested in practice, not a closed achievement |
| Environment Secretary: "Where there are loopholes, I want them closed," pointing to Ofwat's review and "the strengthened Water Bill" [1] | Ofwat's own document defers "changes to specific elements of the rule" to "a later date" with no date given, and separately states the Water Industry Act 1991 already gives it power to act on this without new legislation [2] | Unmatched: no date on either route, and an existing lever goes unmentioned in the press release |
Credit where due
Ofwat is naming the behaviour plainly rather than issuing vague reassurance: "retention payments" and specific base-pay percentages appear in its own document, not extracted by an outside critic. The £10 million and £6.5 million blocked-bonus figures are published with the company count and financial year attached, not rounded into a soundbite [1]. The call for evidence also carries a genuine four-week deadline, 10 December, rather than sitting open-ended, and Ofwat's document is candid that "many water companies did make reasonable efforts to transparently justify and explain their decisions to uplift base pay," a distinction it draws clearly from the companies whose retention schemes it says had "less evident" justification [2].
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. A regulator that publishes the exact scale of a loophole in its own flagship accountability rule, naming the mechanism and the money, is doing real work. But the government's framing of that rule as a finished achievement does not survive contact with the regulator's own admission that it is being worked around, and the promised fix, for either route on offer, has no date next to it. Ofwat's own paperwork says it does not have to wait for a new Act to act on at least the retention-payment loophole. Until it uses that power, or sets a date for the review that might lead somewhere else, "where there are loopholes, I want them closed" is a sentence without a deadline attached to it.
The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the government's white paper describes the executive bonus ban as something already delivered ("We banned unfair executive bonuses"), but Ofwat's own November 2026 call for evidence admits several companies have been circumventing it through retention payments and base-pay rises that sit outside the rule's definition, including individual schemes over £1 million and pay rises over 20 percent. Second, neither of the two routes offered for closing that gap, Ofwat's own review or a future Water Bill, carries a date, and Ofwat's own document notes it already holds powers under the Water Industry Act 1991 to act without new legislation, a point the government's press release does not raise. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about any named executive's or minister's personal conduct; the quoted remarks from the Environment Secretary are cited as the government's public position, not assessed as personal performance. All sources below were fetched directly on 16 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.
Sources
- Water bosses must not be rewarded for failure by another name, says Environment Secretary, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, published 12 November 2026
- Call for evidence: executive pay, Ofwat, November 2026, closes 10 December 2026
- A new vision for water (white paper), Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, updated 19 February 2026
- File:Centre City Tower -Birmingham -UK.jpg, Wikimedia Commons, photo by Erebus555
- Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported licence