TEARDOWN Published 21 November 2026 at 06:44. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

A North Yorkshire gas test has been approved as officially not fracking. A smaller volume of fluid than it is permitted to use at each stage once triggered the earthquake behind the government's fracking moratorium.

4 out of 5 stars4/53 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes

Cayton Bay beach and cliffs on the North Yorkshire heritage coast, with waves breaking on the sand and wooded cliffs curving into the distance.
Cayton Bay, part of the North Yorkshire heritage coast a few miles south of the Burniston site, 11 March 2010. Photo: Alan Walker / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In short. The Environment Agency's 20 November 2026 press release grants Europa Oil and Gas a permit to drill a test borehole, Cloughton 2, near Burniston on the North Yorkshire coast, using a technique called a proppant squeeze. The release says the technique "uses similar principles to hydraulic fracturing" but "is different from the shale gas hydraulic fracturing covered by the Government's current suspension" [[1]]. The difference is a fluid-volume threshold written into the Petroleum Act 1998: anything under 1,000 cubic metres per stage is not legally fracking, whatever it resembles [[2]]. Europa's own proposed volume for Burniston, up to 500 cubic metres per stage, is more than three times the 142 cubic metres injected at the final stage of Cuadrilla's Preston New Road operation in Lancashire in 2019, the stage that triggered a 2.9 ML earthquake and the government's resulting moratorium on fracking [[3]]. A week before the EA's reassurance that its own process was "evidence-based" and would deliver "robust levels of environmental protection" [[1]], the parish council and a campaigner had lodged formal complaints about errors and late amendments in the agency's draft decision document, and about the "evidence-based" fairness of its consultation [[6]]. Three documented mistakes: four stars.

Burniston is a village of a few hundred people on the North Yorkshire coast, wedged between the North York Moors National Park and a stretch of heritage coastline that runs south to Scarborough. On 20 November 2026 the Environment Agency announced it had granted Europa Oil and Gas Limited an environmental permit for Cloughton 2, a test borehole on farmland at the edge of the village, to assess whether the rock beneath it holds enough gas to be worth extracting [[1]].

The borehole itself is not the contested part. The permit covers a technique called a proppant squeeze: pumping a mixture of gelled water and sand into the well under pressure to open small cracks in the rock and improve gas flow. The Environment Agency's own release describes this as using "similar principles to hydraulic fracturing", before stating in the next sentence that "the proposed activity is different from the shale gas hydraulic fracturing covered by the Government's current suspension" [[1]]. That suspension, announced in November 2019, followed seismic activity at Cuadrilla's Preston New Road site in Lancashire that ministers said could not be reliably predicted or controlled [[5]].

The agency's area environment manager, Pat Kelly, added a personal reassurance under the heading "Evidence has been 'carefully reviewed'": "Our assessment is evidence-based and there is a decision document which outlines how we reached our decision. I want to reassure people that the permit will ensure that robust levels of environmental protection are met" [[1]]. The same release states that the decision document itself "will be available shortly", meaning the document the reassurance refers to had not yet been published [[1]].

North Yorkshire Council's planning committee had already refused planning permission for the wider Burniston site, voting 11 to 0 with one abstention on 24 April 2026, against the recommendation of its own planning officers, who had argued the application should be approved [[4]]. Councillors cited harm to the heritage coast, the North York Moors National Park's protected setting, nearby residents and the council's climate commitments; the formal refusal followed in May [[1]][[4]]. Europa has appealed that refusal to the Planning Inspectorate, and the local MP for Scarborough and Whitby, Alison Hume, has said she is prepared to lay an amendment to the government's Energy Independence Bill specifically to close what she calls a fracking loophole [[7]][[8]].

The claims, tested

What the agency and its officers said What the evidence shows Verdict
"The proposed activity is different from the shale gas hydraulic fracturing covered by the Government's current suspension", despite using "similar principles" (EA press release, 20 November 2026) [[1]]; a council planning officer separately told the same application's hearing the technique was "fundamentally different" from higher-volume fracking [[4]] Section 4B of the Petroleum Act 1998 defines "associated hydraulic fracturing" purely by injected-fluid volume: more than 1,000 cubic metres at any stage, or more than 10,000 cubic metres in total [[2]]. Europa's own published proposal is to inject up to 500 cubic metres per stage at Burniston, comfortably under that line [[3]]. The final stage of the Preston New Road operation that prompted the 2019 moratorium injected only 142 cubic metres and still induced a 2.9 ML earthquake; separately, campaigners noted that Burniston's proposed per-stage volume "would exceed that injected by Cuadrilla at Preston New Road... in 2019, which caused earthquakes felt across the Fylde region" [[3]][[4]] The technique exempted from the fracking moratorium is permitted to use more fluid per stage than the operation whose earthquake caused that moratorium
"Our assessment is evidence-based and there is a decision document which outlines how we reached our decision. I want to reassure people that the permit will ensure that robust levels of environmental protection are met" (Pat Kelly, EA area environment manager, 20 November 2026) [[1]] Seven days earlier, Burniston Parish Council filed a formal complaint questioning whether the EA's process was a "fair, transparent and evidence-based process", after the agency's draft decision document had already required "numerous corrections and changes" and an extended consultation; separately, campaigner Dennis May told the EA that "the sheer number of amendments made to the revised draft decision document and permit" pointed to a "wholesale failure in quality assurance" [[6]]. Neither complaint is recorded as resolved before the permit was granted [[6]] The agency's own word, "evidence-based", is the exact quality its own decision document was under formal complaint for lacking, a week before the agency used it to close the matter
North Yorkshire's planning officer called the technique "fundamentally different" from fracking and recommended approval on that basis [[4]] The council's own minerals and waste plan defines fracking by what it does, not by volume: "the fracturing of rocks by injecting a pressurised liquid in order to extract oil or gas", and states this applies "regardless of the volume of fracture fluid used". Campaigners told the same hearing that "this application is a type of hydraulic fracturing or fracking, as defined by your minerals and waste joint plan" [[3]][[4]] The same council relied on a national volume threshold to clear the technique while its own adopted planning policy defines the technique as fracking regardless of volume

What is still open

None of this is settled. Europa's appeal against the planning refusal has not been decided by the Planning Inspectorate, and the environmental permit the EA has now granted does not itself authorise drilling, which still needs that planning question resolved first [[1]][[7]]. The Energy Independence Bill that Hume says she may amend had its first reading on 4 November 2026 and remains at second reading, with no date yet set and no amendment stage reached [[9]]. Her own position is conditional, not yet acted on: "I've been pressing the Government to close the loophole for fracking and I will continue to press them. And if I need to lay an amendment, I will" [[7]].

Credit where due

The Environment Agency's release does not hide the awkward parts. It states plainly, in its own words, that the technique "uses similar principles to hydraulic fracturing" rather than pretending the resemblance away, and it discloses the planning refusal unprompted rather than letting a reader discover it elsewhere [[1]]. Europa's own published figures, 300 to 500 cubic metres per stage, are specific enough that campaigners and planning officers alike could do the volume comparison that this piece relies on; a vaguer disclosure would have made the comparison impossible [[3]]. And the agency did run two public consultations, extending the second after criticism of its draft, which is more scrutiny than a straightforward refusal-free permit would have required [[1]][[6]].

Three documented mistakes. (1) The Environment Agency and a council planning officer both describe the Cloughton 2 proppant squeeze as "different" from fracking, but the sole legal basis for that distinction is a fluid-volume threshold in the Petroleum Act 1998, and Europa's own permitted volume, up to 500 cubic metres per stage, is more than three times the 142 cubic metres that triggered the earthquake behind the fracking moratorium at Preston New Road in 2019. (2) The agency's own area environment manager called its process "evidence-based" and "robust" on the day of the grant, a week after the parish council and a campaigner filed formal complaints about errors and late amendments in that same draft decision document, neither recorded as resolved. (3) North Yorkshire Council relied on the national volume threshold to treat the technique as not fracking, while its own minerals and waste plan defines fracking by technique and says this applies "regardless of the volume of fracture fluid used". Rating: four stars.

Sources

  1. Environment Agency: Environment Agency grants Cloughton gas exploration proposal, 20 November 2026
  2. Petroleum Act 1998, section 4B: meaning of associated hydraulic fracturing
  3. DrillOrDrop: Burniston responses, fracturing and seismicity
  4. DrillOrDrop: Breaking: Burniston gas fracking rejected, 24 April 2026
  5. GOV.UK: Government ends support for fracking, 2 November 2019
  6. DrillOrDrop: EA faces more complaints over Burniston fracking permit, 13 November 2026
  7. Gazette & Herald: 'We are not having fracking in Scarborough,' MP hits back at appeal, 10 November 2026
  8. This is the Coast: Scarborough and Whitby MP vows to close fracking loophole after Burniston rig rejection, 23 June 2026
  9. UK Parliament Bills API: Energy Independence Bill record
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail