The government revised Post Office Horizon compensation rules on 9 November, crediting an unnamed 'Independent Panel decision'. It names no case and does not say if postmasters assessed the week before get a second look.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
In short. On 9 November 2026, the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (BIST) rewrote the Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals assessment framework, the document that tells caseworkers how much to offer postmasters for distress, lost employment and the hours spent investigating phantom shortfalls [1]. GOV.UK's own change note says the revision reflects "findings from a recent Independent Panel decision" [1]. The framework names no case, gives no date and provides no link for that decision, even though the scheme's own guidance describes the Independent Panel as a body that rules on individual disputed claims referred to it after failed settlement talks, not one that sets policy [4]. The document is also silent on whether postmasters assessed in the scheme's first week, before the rewrite, can ask for a second look. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
More than £1,731 million has been paid out across the Post Office's Horizon redress schemes as of 30 September 2026, including £1,080 million through the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS) alone, the route for postmasters who were never prosecuted but still covered shortfalls caused by the Post Office's faulty Horizon IT system [3]. Of that, £756 million has gone to more than 10,000 claimants as a flat £75,000 fixed sum offer, the fast route through the scheme [3].
Since 2 November 2026, postmasters who took that £75,000 and now believe it undervalued their case have had a new route to argue otherwise, a free permission to appeal process into the fuller Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals (HSSA) track, as this site's teardown of that process found. The document that tells a caseworker, and a postmaster's own lawyer, how to value what HSSA actually awards is the Assessment Framework. It is the document BIST rewrote a week later.
What the framework actually says
The Assessment Framework is explicit that its own goal is "full and fair" redress, and that each case is "looked at in the round and decided on its merits" rather than mechanically [2]. Within that, it sets out banded guidance. Core distress and inconvenience offers are "expected to be within the range of £1,000 to £15,000", split into five bands by severity [2], section 3.13.2. Loss of congenial employment, for a postmaster who can show they lost a job they valued because of a Horizon shortfall, "will normally range between £5,000 and £15,000" [2], section 3.16. Time spent investigating a shortfall that cannot be shown as a direct financial loss is folded into distress and inconvenience, calculated in some cases with "a proxy hourly rate (such as £10 per hour)", and expected to land "within a range of £0 to £10,000" [2], sections 3.13.9 to 3.13.10. Compound interest is applied automatically at "a standard rate of 3.45%" without the postmaster needing to calculate it themselves [2], section 2.6.1. The document repeats, more than once, that none of its bands are a ceiling or a floor: "these bands are not limits for what can be claimed under the Process" [2], sections 3.13.5 and 3.14.
All four of those figures, loss of congenial employment, distress and inconvenience, time spent investigating shortfalls and interest, are exactly the four areas GOV.UK's own change log says were revised on 9 November 2026 [1].
The decision behind the rewrite has no name
| BIST's claim | What the evidence shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| The Assessment Framework "has been updated to reflect findings from a recent Independent Panel decision" (GOV.UK change note, 9 November 2026) [1] | Neither the framework's 23 pages, its introduction, nor the GOV.UK publication page gives the cited decision a case reference, a date or a link of any kind [1] [2] | No postmaster, lawyer or journalist can check what was actually decided, or whether this rewrite reflects it in full |
| The Independent Panel exists to deliver settlements under the scheme's "full and fair" standard [4] | The scheme's own guidance describes the Panel's role as applying "judgement to individual cases" referred to it only after bilateral settlement talks fail within two months, a dispute-resolution body, not a standards-setting one [4] | A ruling in what sounds like one person's case has become the stated basis for rewriting the published figures every future claimant is measured against |
| The framework's bands are "not limits", decided case by case in the round [2] | If the bands are only indicative guidance, a single unidentified case is an unusually thin basis for revising the headline figures every postmaster now sees first | Internally inconsistent: the document cannot simultaneously say the numbers do not bind and that one case justified changing them |
The scheme's wider guidance names the Independent Panel's actual composition, a King's Counsel, an accountant, a retail expert and others, and is candid that so far it has been used sparingly: most disputes are settled in bilateral talks before a case ever reaches it [4]. That is precisely why naming the decision matters. A panel that hears only a handful of cases a year making one ruling that reshapes compensation for the whole scheme is a legitimate, even welcome way to correct a framework in light of real experience, if anyone outside government can see what was actually found. As published, nobody can.
No transition rule for the first cohort
The Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals process this framework supports opened for registrations on 2 November 2026 [5]. The Assessment Framework was rewritten seven days later. Nowhere in the document, under any of its sections on evidence, process or outcome, does BIST say whether a postmaster whose claim was assessed in that first week, against the bands this update replaced, can ask for their case to be looked at again under the revised figures [2]. The framework's own fairness principle, restoring postmasters "back into the position they would have been in had it not been for the Horizon-related actions of the Post Office" [2], section 2.1, says nothing about parity between one claimant assessed on 3 November and another assessed on 10 November under a different set of figures for the same category of loss.
Credit where due
Parts of the framework are genuinely claimant-friendly. It explicitly declines to apply "the laws of limitation or time bar" against shortfall or consequential loss claims, regardless of how long ago the underlying events happened [2], section 2.5.1. Interest is calculated and applied automatically, not left to the postmaster to work out. Where a postmaster cannot produce documentary evidence because of how much time has passed, the framework instructs caseworkers to give weight to "clear, plausible and detailed accounts" instead of rejecting the claim [2], section 2.2.4. None of that is undermined by the two findings above; it is the context in which an unexplained rewrite of the compensation figures is more disappointing than it would be from a less careful document.
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. BIST has built a framework that, on its own terms, is candid about uncertainty and generous about evidence. But a government department that cites a specific, singular "Independent Panel decision" as the reason it rewrote the numbers postmasters are assessed against, without saying which decision, when it was made, or what it found, is asking for trust it has not shown its working for. And a scheme that only opened its appeals route a week earlier has nothing to say about the postmasters caught on the wrong side of that week.
The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the framework's own change note cites "a recent Independent Panel decision" as the basis for revising four compensation categories, but neither the framework, the GOV.UK publication page, nor the wider scheme guidance gives that decision a case reference, date or link, despite the Independent Panel's own remit being individual case disputes rather than scheme-wide rulemaking. Second, the framework gives no transition rule for postmasters assessed between the appeals process opening on 2 November 2026 and the framework's rewrite on 9 November 2026, despite its own fairness principle promising to restore every postmaster to the position they would have been in but for the Horizon-related actions of the Post Office. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named individual; the gap examined is institutional, in how BIST documents and communicates a change to its own published framework, not in any decision the Independent Panel itself reached. All sources below were fetched directly on 10 November 2026.
Sources
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, "Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals assessment framework", gov.uk publication page (updated 9 November 2026, checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/horizon-shortfall-scheme-appeals-assessment-framework
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, "Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals Assessment Framework" (PDF), gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6af1991e3d2a37f5a363ac65/horizon_shortfall_scheme_appeals_assessment_framework.pdf
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, "Post Office Horizon financial redress data as of 30 September 2026", gov.uk (modified 22 October 2026, checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/post-office-horizon-financial-redress-and-legal-costs-data-for-2026/post-office-horizon-financial-redress-data-as-of-30-september-2026
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, "Horizon Shortfall Scheme Appeals process guidance and principles", gov.uk guidance (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/guidance/horizon-shortfall-scheme-appeals-process-guidance-and-principles
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, "Fixed sum offer permission to appeal: process guide", gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/horizon-shortfall-scheme-hss-fixed-sum-offer-permission-to-appeal-process/proposed-fixed-sum-offer-permission-to-appeal-process-guide