TEARDOWN Published 17 November 2026 at 06:38. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The government published guidance explaining subscription contract rules as though they are already law. The regulations behind it have no agreed start date, and the criminal offence it describes cannot yet be committed.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Portcullis House, the House of Commons office building in Westminster, seen from across the River Thames.
Portcullis House, Westminster, where select committees sit and statutory instruments await scrutiny. Photo: Ozeye / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

In short. On 19 October 2026 the government published 77 pages of guidance on the new subscription contract rules, telling traders what they must do before 1 January 2027 [[1]] [[2]]. The guidance says plainly that it "has been written as though the subscriptions regime is in force" and that the final version will not appear until the underlying regulations "are made" [[1]], page 6. They have not been. The draft instrument it explains is still printed with its own number left blank: "Draft Statutory Instruments 2026 No. ****" [[3]]. Legislation.gov.uk's commencement note for the Act provisions behind it is equally direct: "not in force at Royal Assent" [[5]]. The guidance describes a criminal offence for breaching the regime, but the section creating that offence is one of the provisions not yet in force [[6]]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

The subscription rules sit in Part 4, Chapter 2 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA), backed by a statutory instrument called the Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026. Together they require traders to give consumers clear pre-contract information, send reminder notices before a trial converts or a contract auto-renews onto a 12-month term, and let consumers exit online as easily as they signed up [[1]], pages 7-8. Consumers get a 14-day cooling-off right when they first sign up and another 14 days after certain renewals [[1]], page 7. None of it is optional detail: businesses that get the pre-contract information wrong at the point of an off-premises sale commit a criminal offence [[1]], page 54.

Written as if it already applies

The guidance does not hide the gap between what it describes and what currently exists. Page 6 carries what the document itself calls "a note on this draft guidance": "This draft guidance has been published alongside the laying of the Draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 in Parliament. These Draft Regulations must be approved by Parliament before they can come into force" [[1]], page 6. It goes further: "This guidance has been written as though the subscriptions regime is in force," and the primary Act provisions that create that regime "have been passed by Parliament and received Royal Assent but [are] not yet in force" [[1]], page 6. The commitment on timing is a single sentence: "This final guidance will be published after the Draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 are made" [[1]], page 6. No date, and no fallback if that does not happen soon enough to matter.

The instrument does not have a number yet

The strength of that gap is visible on the face of the regulations themselves. The statutory instrument laid before Parliament on 19 October 2026 is headed "Draft Statutory Instruments 2026 No. ****" [[3]] - the asterisks are the placeholder the Statutory Instruments Office leaves until an instrument is actually made and given a real number. Legislation.gov.uk's own commencement field for it reads "Made" followed by nothing [[3]]. A companion instrument, the consequential amendments regulations that update other legislation to fit the new regime, is in the same state: laid 19 October 2026, "Made" blank, due to come into force "1st January 2027" on a date that depends on a step that has not happened [[4]]. Both instruments carry the same target commencement date the guidance assumes throughout: 1 January 2027, now six weeks away [[1]], page 7; [[3]]; [[4]].

The offence cannot be committed yet either

Section 268 of the DMCCA makes it a criminal offence for a trader to fail to give a consumer the required cooling-off information when signing them up to an off-premises subscription contract, with a fine on conviction under section 271 [[1]], page 54. The guidance explains this offence in detail, including a defence of due diligence and provision for offences committed by company officers [[1]], page 54. What it does not say in that section is that section 268 itself is switched off. Legislation.gov.uk's commentary on section 268 states: "S. 268 not in force at Royal Assent, see s. 339(1)" [[6]], the identical note attached to section 254, the section defining what a subscription contract is in the first place [[5]]. Until a commencement order is made, the offence the guidance describes cannot legally be committed by anyone, because the provision that creates it is not operative law. The guidance does not flag this anywhere in the offences section itself; a reader would need to check legislation.gov.uk directly, as this piece did, to find it out.

Eleven questions, none about the gap

Section 12 of the guidance answers eleven frequently asked questions: whether the rules apply retrospectively, how bundled products are treated, whether overseas traders are caught, what counts as a "durable medium" for notices [[1]], pages 60-62. None of them asks what a trader should do if Parliament has not approved the regulations by 1 January 2027, or what happens to contracts entered into in the gap between the assumed start date and the regulations actually being made. The guidance's own account of its status, on page 6, is the only place that gap is acknowledged at all, and it offers no contingency beyond waiting for "final guidance" after the fact.

Credit where due

The enforcement machinery this regime will eventually use is not new or untested. The CMA's direct consumer enforcement powers under Part 3 of the DMCCA, including fines of up to £300,000 or 10% of global turnover, have been live since 6 April 2025, and the CMA's own procedural guidance for using them, CMA200, has been published and stable since 14 March 2025 [[7]], page 1. Part 4, Chapter 2 is listed in the schedules that bring subscription contracts within that regime once it commences [[1]], page 56. The guidance's substance, on pre-contract information, reminder notices and online exit, is detailed and specific rather than vague. The problem this piece raises is not the content of the guidance but the gap between how it is written and what is currently in force.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the record shows Verdict
"This guidance has been written as though the subscriptions regime is in force" (page 6) [[1]] Legislation.gov.uk confirms sections 254 and 268 of the DMCCA are "not in force at Royal Assent" [[5]] [[6]], and the regulations the guidance explains are a draft instrument still numbered "2026 No. ****" with a blank Made date [[3]] The guidance describes a regime that, as of this piece's publication, is not operative law
The guidance sets out a criminal offence under section 268 for failing to give cooling-off information at an off-premises sale (page 54) [[1]] Section 268 is one of the provisions legislation.gov.uk confirms is not yet in force [[6]] The offence the guidance describes cannot currently be committed by anyone

The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, the guidance is written throughout as though the subscription contract regime already applies, while legislation.gov.uk confirms the Act provisions behind it, including the offence provision, are not in force, and the regulations it explains carry no instrument number and no Made date; second, the guidance's own eleven-question FAQ never addresses what happens if Parliament has not approved the regulations before the 1 January 2027 deadline the guidance assumes throughout, leaving traders with no stated contingency. Two mistakes in the 1-to-3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about whether Parliament will approve the regulations in time, or about the merits of the subscription rules themselves; it reports what the guidance's own text says about its legal status, and what legislation.gov.uk's own commencement record says about the provisions it explains. All sources below were fetched directly on 17 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.

Sources

  1. Guidance on the subscription contracts rules, Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, published October 2026
  2. Subscription contracts, GOV.UK, first published 19 October 2026
  3. The Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026, draft as laid, legislation.gov.uk
  4. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (Subscription Contracts) (Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2026, draft as laid, legislation.gov.uk
  5. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 254 (commencement note), legislation.gov.uk
  6. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 268 (commencement note), legislation.gov.uk
  7. CMA200: Direct consumer enforcement guidance, Competition and Markets Authority, published 14 March 2025
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail