Making Tax Digital already covers hundreds of thousands of sole traders and landlords, with millions more to come. Last month's Budget promised an exemption for the customers it cannot sign up, with no way yet to claim it.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. Making Tax Digital for Income Tax already requires an estimated 780,000 sole traders and landlords to keep digital records and file quarterly, with a further 970,000 due to join in April 2027 [3]. In the Overview of Tax Legislation and Rates published alongside Budget 2026, the government commits to exempting qualifying-care-relief claimants and non-resident customers by "secondary legislation... before April 2027," then adds, in the same paragraph, that "a small number of insolvent customers who are not currently able to sign up" will also not be required to use the service [1]. No number, no application route and no date are given for that group. HMRC's own public exemptions guidance, last updated the same week as the Budget document, has no section implementing it; its only insolvency clause, unchanged since January, covers a different, already-signed-up group and tells them "you will not be exempt and should continue to use the service" [2]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax is not a future reform. It is live now. HMRC's own guidance states plainly: "You need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax from 6 April 2026 if your total annual income from self-employment and property is over £50,000" [5]. A year before that start date, HMRC's Director of Making Tax Digital, Craig Ogilvie, put a number on who that meant: "around 780,000 self-employed individuals and landlords will be required to use MTD for Income Tax from April 2026," with "a further 970,000 joining from April 2027" when the threshold drops to £30,000 [3]. By August 2026, HMRC reported more than 570,000 customers already signed up and over 436,000 sole traders and landlords who had successfully filed their first quarterly update [4]. This is a mandate measured in hundreds of thousands now, heading for millions.
A promise with no number, no process and no date
Budget 2026 fell on 28 October. The Overview of Tax Legislation and Rates (OOTLAR) published that day, and last updated 12 November, sets out section 2.37, "MTD for Income Tax: Exemptions." Its own words: "the government will exempt the following groups from MTD for Income Tax until further notice: those eligible for qualifying care relief, non-UK resident foreign entertainers and sportspeople and expected non-resident customers. Secondary legislation will be introduced before April 2027" [1]. That sentence gives three groups a mechanism and a deadline.
The very next sentence adds a fourth group, in a different register: "As the government set out previously, some customers for whom HMRC cannot provide a digital service will not be required to use MTD for Income Tax - this will include a small number of insolvent customers who are not currently able to sign up" [1]. "A small number" is not a figure. "Until further notice" is not a date. And unlike the sentence before it, this one names no secondary legislation and no timetable at all. The group the government singles out as people its own system is technically incapable of serving is the one group given nothing to hold the promise to.
The only guidance on insolvency says something else
HMRC's public-facing exemptions guidance, the page a sole trader or landlord would actually check to find out whether they qualify, lists automatic exemptions, digitally-excluded exemptions and several time-limited categories [2]. Two of the three groups named in OOTLAR 2.37 are already there: qualifying care relief is listed as an automatic exemption, and non-resident and foreign entertainer or sportsperson status are covered through the SA109 exemption route [2]. The fourth group is not.
The page's only sentence mentioning insolvency reads: "If your VAT exemption is because you're going through an insolvency procedure and you are signed up to Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, you will not be exempt and should continue to use the service" [2]. That text was added on 6 January 2026, nearly ten months before the Budget promise, and it addresses the opposite situation: someone already signed up, told to carry on. It is not a route to the exemption OOTLAR 2.37 describes, and the page's own update log shows no entry since adding or changing anything about customers HMRC "cannot provide a digital service" to. A reader going through insolvency who cannot sign up today has no form, no number to call that the page names for this purpose, and no criteria to check themselves against.
The claims, tested
| The document's own words | What the evidence shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| OOTLAR 2.37: qualifying-care-relief claimants and non-resident customers get "secondary legislation... before April 2027" [1] | Both groups are already implemented in HMRC's live exemptions guidance, as an automatic exemption and via the SA109 route respectively [2] | Matches: a dated commitment, already delivered in guidance |
| Same clause, same paragraph: "a small number of insolvent customers who are not currently able to sign up" will also "not be required to use MTD for Income Tax" [1] | No number, no application process and no legislative date are given for this group anywhere on gov.uk; the only guidance page mentioning insolvency covers a different, already-signed-up cohort and does not exempt them [2] | Unmatched: a promise with no number, no process and no date |
Credit where due
The underlying admission is a genuinely honest one. HMRC did not have to acknowledge, in a Budget document read mainly by tax professionals, that its own digital service cannot currently onboard every customer it has mandated; many organisations would have left that gap unstated rather than invite the question this piece asks. The two groups it has fully implemented, qualifying care relief and non-resident customers, show the guidance machinery does work when HMRC puts a date against the commitment: both appeared in the exemptions page within months of being announced. The penalty easement in the preceding paragraph of the same OOTLAR section, sparing taxpayers joining in April 2027 from late-submission penalty points on their first four quarterly updates, is also a sensible, proportionate response to a known transition risk [1].
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. A mandate already covering hundreds of thousands of sole traders and landlords, heading for millions more, is not a small administrative corner. Within that mandate, the government has publicly promised not to force its service on customers it admits it cannot serve, which is the right call. But it gave that promise no number, no process and no date, the only commitment in its own exemptions clause left that open, and the one page the public would check for help still answers a different question for a different group of insolvent customers. Until that gap closes, the customers it most concerns have nothing to point to.
The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, OOTLAR section 2.37 promises to exempt "a small number of insolvent customers who are not currently able to sign up" from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, but gives no number, no application process and no date, unlike the other two groups named in the same clause, which both carry a legislative deadline and are already live in guidance. Second, the only sentence HMRC's public exemptions guidance devotes to insolvency, unchanged since 6 January 2026, addresses a different, already-signed-up cohort and tells them to continue using the service, leaving no stated route for the group the Budget document describes. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about any named official's conduct; the quoted remarks from HMRC's Director of Making Tax Digital are cited as the department's public position, not assessed as personal performance. All sources below were fetched directly on 16 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.
Sources
- Budget 2026 - Overview of Tax Legislation and Rates (OOTLAR), section 2.37: MTD for Income Tax: Exemptions, HM Treasury / HM Revenue and Customs, published 28 October 2026, last updated 12 November 2026
- Find out if you can get an exemption from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, HM Revenue and Customs, last updated 12 November 2026
- One year until Making Tax Digital for Income Tax launches, HM Revenue and Customs, 22 April 2025
- 436,000 sole traders and landlords make their tax digital, HM Revenue and Customs, 12 August 2026
- Sign up for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, HM Revenue and Customs, last updated 13 October 2026
- File:Government Offices Great George Street.jpg, Wikimedia Commons, photo by Carlos Delgado, 14 October 2011
- Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported licence