Ofgem's own review named debt recovery as exactly where it wanted power to hold bosses personally accountable. Its first live debt-recovery case, seven months on, still cannot touch a single executive.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero's April 2026 review of Ofgem proposed giving the regulator an Individual Accountability Mechanism, so that "designated individuals could be personally accountable for areas such as customer service or debt services" [1]. Legislating it was conditioned on one line: "when parliamentary time allows", with no date attached [1]. On 5 November 2026, Ofgem opened a live investigation into ScottishPower over exactly that scenario, backbilling and debt recovery, but the only thing it can hold to account is the company [2]. The Energy Independence Bill, introduced to Parliament the day before and described by the government as delivering "the legislative changes required to address the findings of the Ofgem Review", does not mention individual accountability once across the 28 factsheets published to explain it [3] [4]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Ofgem can fine an energy supplier. It cannot touch the executive who signed off the decision that got the company fined. The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero's review of the regulator, published 22 April 2026 after an eighteen-month process, says so plainly: "for sectoral matters, Ofgem is able only to take action against licensees (meaning the regulated company) rather than against senior staff within the company", which "means Ofgem both cannot hold individuals directly accountable, and that it has at best indirect recourse when a senior individual leaves a licensee" [1]. The review's own example of why that matters is United Gas and Power, "found to have deliberately overcharged customers to remedy a shortfall in their budget" [1], a company decision with no route back to the people who made it.
A gap named, with no date attached
The review's answer is Action 19: "Provide Ofgem with the power to introduce an Individual Accountability Mechanism (IAM) to allow it to hold senior energy company staff directly accountable for their actions" [1]. The document is specific about where that power could reach. It describes a regime "requiring licensees to designate senior management functions", where "designated individuals could be personally accountable for areas such as customer service or debt services" [1]. Annex B's own table of actions records, against Action 19, that legislation is required, that it is DESNZ's job to legislate and Ofgem's job to consult and implement, and gives no target date for either step [1]. The only commitment attached anywhere in the document is a single sentence: "When parliamentary time allows, we will legislate to give Ofgem the necessary powers to introduce such a regime" [1].
Seven months later, debt services stopped being a hypothetical example. On 5 November 2026, Ofgem opened a formal investigation into whether ScottishPower Energy Retail Limited "has complied with its obligations on backbilling, identifying and supporting customers in vulnerable situations, assessing customers' ability to pay, and treating customers fairly" [2]. The notice names five Standard Licence Conditions under investigation, covering fair treatment of vulnerable customers, the twelve-month limit on backbilling, the Priority Services Register, and support for customers in payment difficulty [2]. Every one of those obligations sits inside what the review called "debt services". None of Ofgem's current powers reaches past the licensee's name on the notice.
| The review's own words | The live case testing them | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Designated individuals "could be personally accountable for areas such as customer service or debt services" under a new Individual Accountability Mechanism [1] | Ofgem's 5 November 2026 investigation into ScottishPower covers backbilling, vulnerable-customer support and payment-difficulty obligations, but is framed entirely against the company: "Investigation into ScottishPower and its compliance with gas and electricity supply standard licence conditions" [2] | The first debt-services case since the review named the category has no individual accountability route to use, because the mechanism the review proposed for it does not exist |
| "When parliamentary time allows, we will legislate to give Ofgem the necessary powers to introduce such a regime" [1] | No legislation has been laid specifically for the Individual Accountability Mechanism in the seven months since, and the review's own Annex B gives no target date [1] | A commitment with no date is not a commitment a reader, or a regulator, can hold the department to |
The bill that was supposed to fix this
One day before the ScottishPower investigation opened, the government introduced the Energy Independence Bill to Parliament, on 4 November 2026 [5]. DESNZ's own factsheet on the bill's Ofgem measures is explicit about the link: "these measures will take forward the legislative changes required to address the findings of the Ofgem Review and ensure that it... can act effectively in the interest of all consumers" [3]. On enforcement specifically, the same factsheet says only that the bill is "revising its enforcement powers" and "extending and updating Ofgem's statutory powers" so the regulator can "take a more robust approach to enforcement" [3]. It does not name the Individual Accountability Mechanism, senior managers, or bonus clawback anywhere in its text.
That silence is not confined to one factsheet. The government published 28 separate factsheets explaining the bill's measures, covering everything from heat network charging to radioactive waste [4]. Not one of their titles, and none of the enforcement-focused factsheet's own text, addresses individual accountability for energy company staff. The bill passed first reading on 4 November 2026 and sits at second reading, with no date yet scheduled for that stage [5].
| The bill's own billing | What its own supporting documents show | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| The Energy Independence Bill's Ofgem factsheet says its measures "take forward the legislative changes required to address the findings of the Ofgem Review" [3] | None of the 28 published factsheets explaining the bill's measures mentions individual accountability, senior managers, or bonus clawback [4] | A bill pitched as delivering the review's promises does not, on the government's own explanation of it, address this specific one |
| The review proposed the Individual Accountability Mechanism as part of a package the government says it is now legislating [1] | The bill delivering that package is seven months old at second reading, with no date set for that stage and Royal Assent further off still [5] | Even on the most generous reading, where this measure is in the bill but simply not singled out in a factsheet, nothing changes for a case like ScottishPower's until long after Royal Assent, consultation, and implementation |
Credit where due
Nothing here is hidden. The review names the accountability gap candidly, cites a real historical case against it, and discloses in its own published table that legislation is required rather than letting the dependency go unstated [1]. Ofgem's investigation notice is appropriately neutral about ScottishPower, stating outright that opening it "does not imply that we have made any findings about non-compliance" [2], the correct posture for a live case. And the review's broader diagnosis, that Ofgem's statutory toolkit has not kept pace with a changing energy market, is argued with real examples rather than asserted.
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. A government review that names the exact kind of case where it wants new power to reach individuals, then leaves that power's start date to "when parliamentary time allows", should not be surprised when the first such case arrives with nothing to use. And a bill published as the vehicle for delivering that review's findings should say so for every finding it actually delivers, not leave readers to infer from an absence across 28 documents whether one promise made it in at all.
The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the Ofgem Review names debt services as an illustrative scope for a new Individual Accountability Mechanism, then attaches no date to legislating it beyond "when parliamentary time allows"; Ofgem's 5 November 2026 investigation into ScottishPower, covering exactly that ground, proceeds seven months later with no individual accountability route available, only company-level enforcement. Second, the Energy Independence Bill's own factsheet describes itself as delivering the legislative changes the review found necessary, yet none of the government's 28 published factsheets explaining the bill's measures, including the one dedicated to Ofgem's powers, mentions individual accountability, senior managers, or bonus clawback by name. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of ScottishPower or any named individual; the ScottishPower investigation is open, and Ofgem states explicitly that opening it implies no finding of non-compliance. Both gaps described here are drawn from the review's own published text, the investigation's own published notice, and the bill's own published factsheets, read against each other. All sources below were fetched directly on 10 November 2026.
Sources
- Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, "Ofgem Review: final report" (published 22 April 2026), gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/ofgem-review-2026/ofgem-review-final-report
- Ofgem, "ScottishPower: backbilling and debt recovery" (enforcement case, opened 5 November 2026), ofgem.gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/publications/scottishpower-backbilling-and-debt-recovery
- Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, "Measures to strengthen Ofgem" (Energy Independence Bill factsheet, published 4 November 2026), gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/energy-independence-bill-factsheets/measures-to-strengthen-ofgem
- Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, "Energy Independence Bill: factsheets" (index of 28 factsheets, published 4 November 2026), gov.uk (checked 10 November 2026). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/energy-independence-bill-factsheets
- UK Parliament, Bills API record for the Energy Independence Bill (Bill 4319, introduced 4 November 2026, currently at second reading) (checked 10 November 2026). https://bills-api.parliament.uk/api/v1/Bills/4319