TEARDOWN Published 19 November 2026 at 08:14. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

New guidance tells Ofgem to favour British suppliers in electricity network contracts, part of a plan billed as bringing bills down. Its own text admits that could cost billpayers more first, and no network company has to join in.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes

Electricity transmission towers carrying power lines across open farmland at the National Grid training centre near Eakring, Nottinghamshire.
Electricity transmission towers at National Grid's training centre near Eakring, Nottinghamshire, 25 October 2015. Photo: Humphrey Bolton / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In short. On 14 September 2026 the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero issued statutory guidance telling Ofgem to push electricity network owners towards British suppliers; it came into force on 17 November 2026 [1]. The guidance leans on the government's promise of "an energy system that brings down bills for households and business for good" (p.4) to justify the push, then concedes on page 9 that favouring domestic firms "may come with a short-term cost trade-off", funded by billpayers, with no number put on it. The lever itself does not bind anyone: it is a "voluntary minimum 10% social value weighting" (p.5) that network owners are free to ignore, and Ofgem's own duty under the Electricity Act 1989 is only to "have regard to" the guidance (p.1), not to apply it. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

Electricity networks, the transmission and distribution wires that carry power from generators to homes and industry, sit at the centre of the government's growth and net zero plans, and the investment going into them is large by any measure. The guidance itself cites a National Wealth Fund package of £600m in lending to Iberdrola/Scottish Power, mobilising a further £750m in private finance, plus an £800m guarantee to SSEN Transmission, as evidence of the scale already in motion (p.4) [1]. That is before counting the rest of the sector's multi-year build-out, all of it ultimately recovered through network charges on household and business energy bills.

Into that spending, the Secretary of State has issued guidance under section 3B of the Electricity Act 1989 asking the Gas and Electricity Markets Authority, Ofgem's governing body, to use its regulatory influence over network owners' procurement to favour UK-based suppliers, jobs and supply chains. The stated aim is to replicate, for the energy networks sector, the "social value" weighting the government already applies to its own contracts.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the document's own other words show Verdict
The guidance invokes the Modern Industrial Strategy's "absolute imperative" of "building an energy system that brings down bills for households and business for good" (p.4) as the backdrop for its growth push [1] Five pages later, the same document says favouring domestic firms in network procurement "may come with a short-term cost trade-off" (p.9), and that this cost falls on a sector whose investment is "funded by billpayers" (p.5) [1] A bills-down narrative used to justify a policy the document itself says may raise costs first, with no figure, cap or timeframe attached to the admitted rise
The guidance asks Ofgem to pursue a "voluntary minimum 10% social value weighting" in network procurement, rising to a "20% social value weighting as a longer-term ambition" (p.5) [1] The same document says "network owners are not central government organisations within scope of PPN 026" (p.5), that private utilities "are not currently subject to Section 13 of the Procurement Act [20]23, nor the NPPS" (p.17), that the social value model itself "is not a mandatory content requirement" even where it does apply (p.8), and that Ofgem's own duty is only to "have regard to" the guidance, not comply with it (p.1) [1] A headline percentage lever that nobody in the chain, network owner, regulator or the policy itself, is obliged to use

A cost the document names but does not size

Paragraph 29 is the only place the guidance acknowledges what favouring domestic suppliers over the cheapest available bidder can mean in practice: "The Authority should actively recognise that domestic firms winning contracts can be good for consumers where the location and continuity of domestic productive capability reduces the expected whole-system cost of delivering reliable energy infrastructure. The government recognises that this may come with a short-term cost trade-off" (p.9) [1]. That sentence is the entire quantification offered anywhere in the 22-page document. No percentage, no cash figure, no affected-bill estimate, and no date by which the trade-off is expected to end, accompanies it.

The absence matters because the money involved does not come from general taxation. Paragraph 14 states plainly that the investment behind this push is "funded by billpayers" (p.5) [1], the same households and businesses the guidance's opening pages promise will see bills come down as a result of this agenda. This site's own teardown of the Autumn Budget 2026 already found the government's gas standing-charge pledge, a separate bills-down commitment made the same autumn, running a year behind the Chancellor's public framing of it [2]. This guidance adds a second, admitted but unquantified cost risk to the same billpayers, under the same rhetorical banner, on a different lever entirely.

A lever nobody has to pull

The guidance is explicit that the procurement push it describes sits outside the policy framework that would normally give it force. Electricity network procurements, it says, "are not in scope of these revised guidelines, given that Network Owners are not central government organisations within scope of PPN 026" (p.5) [1], the Cabinet Office policy that sets a mandatory 20 percent social value weighting for central government contracts over £5 million. Rather than extending that mandatory regime, the guidance asks Ofgem to "encourage" a "voluntary minimum 10% social value weighting" and separately "welcomes" discussion of working towards the 20 percent figure "as a longer-term ambition" (p.5) [1]. Two different numbers, both voluntary, are offered as though the gap between them were a matter of pace rather than legal force.

That gap is structural, not incidental. The guidance's own glossary confirms "private utilities are not currently subject to Section 13 of the Procurement Act [20]23, nor the" National Procurement Policy Statement (p.17) [1], the legislation that makes social value weighting mandatory where it does bite. Even inside that mandatory regime, the guidance notes, the social value model itself "is not a mandatory content requirement" (p.8) [1]. And above all of that sits the Authority's own statutory duty, which the guidance quotes from the Electricity Act 1989 itself: Ofgem "shall, in carrying out its functions [...] have regard to any guidance [so] issued" (p.1) [1], a duty to note the advice, not to act on it. Three separate layers, the network owners, the policy regime and the regulator's own statutory duty, are each voluntary or advisory in turn.

Accountability for all of this runs no further than conversation. The guidance asks the Authority to "discuss progress" against its considerations "with senior officials and/or ministers on a quarterly basis" and to "provide a further update on progress in writing for publication on an annual basis" (p.11) [1]. No target is set for either the 10 percent or 20 percent weighting, and nothing in the document describes a consequence if, a year from now, neither number has moved.

Credit where due

The guidance is more candid than most documents of its kind in admitting, however briefly, that its own preferred policy carries a cost risk to the people paying for it; many comparable statements simply assert a policy is costless. It also takes care to preserve the legal guard rails around that policy: the social value model, it says twice, "must be applied in a way that is proportionate, does not create unnecessary burdens for suppliers or barriers to participation, and does not discriminate against treaty state suppliers or violate the UK's international law obligations" under World Trade Organisation rules (p.8) [1]. A domestic-preference policy that respected neither constraint would be a bigger problem than an unquantified one.

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes. The guidance is honest, in one sentence, that its central lever may cost billpayers more before it helps them, but it never sizes that cost, caps it, or dates its end, despite opening by invoking a bills-down promise to justify the policy. And the lever it describes binds nobody: not the network owners asked to adopt it, not the wider procurement regime it borrows its numbers from, and not Ofgem itself, whose statutory duty is only to take note of the guidance. A document that wanted its growth agenda for electricity networks to be more than aspiration would have had to choose one of those three points to make mandatory. This one chose none.

The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, the guidance invokes a promise that growth policy will help "build an energy system that brings down bills for households and business for good" (p.4) to justify a domestic-supplier procurement push, then admits on page 9 that the push "may come with a short-term cost trade-off" funded by billpayers, without giving any figure, cap or end date for that cost; second, the guidance's headline lever, a "voluntary minimum 10% social value weighting" rising to a 20 percent "longer-term ambition" (p.5), binds no one in the chain that would have to deliver it, since network owners sit outside the mandatory procurement regime the figures are borrowed from (p.5, p.17), the social value model is "not a mandatory content requirement" even where it does apply (p.8), and Ofgem's own statutory duty is only to "have regard to" the guidance (p.1). Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named official; the criticism is confined to the guidance document's own wording and the legal framework it operates within. Both sources below were fetched directly on 19 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.

Sources

  1. Electricity networks growth: social and environmental guidance to GEMA, Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, published 14 September 2026, in force 17 November 2026
  2. The Chancellor said gas standing charges end next year. His own Budget, published the same day, promises only "by the end of 2027 or as soon as possible after then", trackedchanges.co.uk, 31 October 2026
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail