TEARDOWN Published 13 November 2026 at 05:25. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

A new power promises to stop copycat designs before small studios face costly legal fights. The government's own response says it will check only some applications, under guidance that does not exist yet.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

The Rolls Building on Fetter Lane in the City of London, home of the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court.
The Rolls Building, Fetter Lane, City of London, home of the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court, 1 November 2021. Photo: Roger Green / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

In short. The Intellectual Property Office's response to its consultation on the UK designs framework, published 4 November 2026, says the government "will legislate when parliamentary time allows to give the registrar the power to conduct a search and examination of designs on the grounds of novelty and individual character" [1] (p.13). The same page adds that "in practice, the search and examination will be carried out for a proportion of applications. This will be informed by guidance with criteria to inform when an examiner should conduct a search" [1] (p.13). The IPO's press release announcing the same reforms says only that "the IPO will gain powers to evaluate whether designs are genuinely new before registration" [2], with no mention of a proportion, or of guidance that has not yet been written. Every substantive change in the 52-page response, including this one, is qualified "when parliamentary time allows", with no date given anywhere in the document. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

A design registered without being checked for novelty is not a technicality. It is, on the Intellectual Property Office's own account, a mechanism several respondents to its consultation said they had already been hit by: someone else registers a product they did not create, a photograph lifted from a rival's website, or a generic item nobody actually designed, then uses the registration to send takedown notices to online marketplaces. Businesses that have had to fight one of these registrations reported costs of "between £10,000 and more than £50,000 to resolve these cases" [2]. On 4 November 2026 the IPO published its response to a consultation that ran from September to November 2025, announcing a package it says will fix this. Read the 52-page response document behind the press release, and the fix is narrower, and less dated, than the announcement makes it sound.

A power that covers an unpublished "proportion"

The press release's framing is unqualified. "The IPO will gain powers to evaluate whether designs are genuinely new before registration", it says, before describing a second strand of the same power: the office "will also be able to consider whether a design application has 'individual character'" [2]. Read on its own, that describes a new check against which a design application will be tested. The government's own response, three pages into its "Detail of outcome" section, describes something narrower. The consultation had explicitly ruled out reintroducing "a full search and examination of all design applications", because "users value the speed and low-cost of the current registration system" [1] (p.11). Having ruled that out, the government settled on the version respondents described as the most limited of the options on the table: a "targeted, discretionary search" [1] (p.12), which the final conclusion confirms will run on "a proportion of applications", decided by "guidance with criteria to inform when an examiner should conduct a search" [1] (p.13). That guidance does not exist yet. A reader of the press release alone has no way of knowing that the new power will not touch most applications, or that the criteria for which ones it will touch have not been written.

The response document itself records why this matters to the scale of the problem it describes. On the same page as the new power's scope, it notes that "some questioned whether the estimated 9% of designs registered that aren't new justifies changes to the registration process" [1] (p.12), a figure the document does not itself source or verify, but reports as a live question among the people responding. Whatever the true rate, a search power whose own operating criteria are still unwritten cannot yet be checked against it, by the IPO or by anyone else.

"When parliamentary time allows", with no date attached

The search power is not an isolated case of a missing date. Every one of the response's substantive commitments carries the same qualifier. Section A promises the government will "legislate when parliamentary time allows" for the search power and to scrap a statutory search-service obligation [1] (p.11). Section B uses the identical phrase for the new 30-month deferment period [1] (p.17). Section C uses it again for protecting animated and digital designs [1] (p.20), and Section E for giving the registrar power to object to unlawful applications and to rectify the register [1] (p.27). None of the four fixes a date, a bill, or a parliamentary session. The companion proposal on bad faith filings is even less advanced: the government says it "will undertake further work to define what behaviour would constitute bad faith and determine the evidential threshold", which "will inform the decision on whether to seek a legislative vehicle" [1] (p.14), meaning the government has not yet decided whether to try to legislate for it at all.

The process behind this response has already run for four years without reaching a date: a call for views in 2022, a further survey in February 2025, a twelve-week consultation that closed in November 2025, and this response in November 2026 [1] (p.6). Its own Assessment of Impacts section, in its final paragraph, confirms that the modelling behind these changes is not finished either: "these suggestions have been noted and attempts will be made to include a wider set of impacts in any final Impact Assessments" [1] (p.49). Four years into the review, there is still no finished costing for the reforms it recommends, and no date by which any of them becomes law.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the record actually shows Verdict
Press release: "the IPO will gain powers to evaluate whether designs are genuinely new before registration" [2] The response document (p.13) limits this in practice to "a proportion of applications", under guidance that "will be informed by" criteria not yet written [1] The public announcement omits the scope limit stated in the government's own formal response
The response commits to legislate on search powers, deferment, digital designs and register rectification "when parliamentary time allows" (pp.11, 17, 20, 27) [1] No date, bill or session is named for any of the four; the Assessment of Impacts (p.49) says a final Impact Assessment is still pending, four years after the review began A package billed as "major reforms" carries no committed timetable for becoming law

Credit where due

Two of the government's decisions here are genuine, evidence-led restraint rather than announcement for its own sake. It rejected the more complex two-stage registration system that many respondents themselves criticised as adding delay, cost and procedural complexity [1] (pp.12-13). And on criminal sanctions for unregistered design infringement, a change some respondents wanted, it declined on the explicit grounds that it had "not received sufficiently robust evidence to demonstrate that introducing criminal offences for unregistered designs would be a balanced and proportionate remedy" [1] (p.46), rather than adding a criminal offence to look tough. The 30-month deferment period, bringing the UK into line with the EU and Hague systems, is also a clean, unhedged commitment on the substance, even if its date is not yet fixed.

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes. Both are mistakes of omission, not invention: nothing in the IPO's press release is false on its own terms, and the response document itself discloses the limits that the announcement leaves out. But a small design studio reading the headline alone would reasonably conclude that every new design application will now be checked against a copycat before it reaches the register. The government's own 52-page response says that is not what is being built, not yet, and not for a date it is willing to name.

The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the IPO's press release of 4 November 2026 describes the new search and examination power as the office being able "to evaluate whether designs are genuinely new before registration", without disclosing that the government's own formal response (p.13) limits this in practice to "a proportion of applications", decided under guidance that has not yet been published. Second, every substantive reform in the 52-page response, including the search power, the 30-month deferment period, digital design protection and the registrar's rectification powers, is qualified "when parliamentary time allows" with no date, bill or parliamentary session named anywhere in the document, and the response's own Assessment of Impacts (p.49) confirms a final Impact Assessment is still pending four years into the review. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the personal conduct of any named individual; the claims tested are the government's own published response document and press release. All sources below were fetched directly on 13 November 2026.

Sources

  1. Government response to the consultation on changes to the UK designs framework (CP 1697), Intellectual Property Office, published 4 November 2026
  2. Designers to get stronger and simpler protection in major reforms, Intellectual Property Office, published 4 November 2026
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail