TEARDOWN Published 20 November 2026 at 02:40. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

MPs told the government to fix a £250 cap on ground rents by law, in force two months after Royal Assent. Ministers refused, keeping the decision for themselves and promising only to aim for six months, with no guaranteed date at all.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

A purpose-built block of leasehold flats, Rosemary Court, York.
Purpose-built flats, Rosemary Court, York, 3 March 2022. Photo: Christine Johnstone / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

In short. The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill had its first reading in the Commons on 19 November 2026, the same day the government published its response to the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee's pre-legislative scrutiny report [1]. The Committee's Recommendation 2 asked for a fixed commencement clause bringing the £250 ground rent cap into force two months after Royal Assent (p.9). The government's own response says that is "not feasible" and keeps a discretionary commencement power, promising only to "aim" for six months (p.9), three times the Committee's timetable and not a guarantee. The Bill's answer to landlords dodging the cap through loopholes similarly rests on a power to appoint a lead enforcement authority, not a duty to do so, with no date attached (p.10) and the wider regime only "kept under review" (p.11). Two documented mistakes: four stars.

Leasehold reform has been a live promise across two governments. The draft Bill went out for scrutiny on 27 January 2026; the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee took evidence, made 56 recommendations in its 1st Report on 27 May 2026, and told ministers the Bill needed to "go further and faster" [2]. The government's modelling of just one part of that reform, the switch to a peppercorn ground rent cap, puts the value transferred from freeholders to leaseholders at somewhere between £12.3bn and £19.7bn depending on how long the transition runs (p.8) [1]. This is not a small reform.

The claims, tested

The Committee's recommendation The government's own response Verdict
Recommendation 2: the final Bill "must include a commencement clause for the £250 cap on ground rents to come into force two months after the Act is given Royal Assent," not at a date ministers choose later, as the draft Bill allowed (p.9) [1] "The Government does not consider it feasible to include a fixed commencement date in the Bill for the ground rent measures two months after Royal Assent" (p.9); instead it will retain "a commencement power to bring the ground rent measures into force by regulations" and "will aim to bring the cap into force six months after Royal Assent" (p.9) [1] The fixed deadline MPs asked for is refused outright; the replacement is a non-binding aim, at three times the length
Recommendation 3: the cap "must" be designed so it cannot be evaded by attributing ground rent to appurtenant property, such as parking spaces, or by similar charges hidden in headleases (p.10) [1] The Bill "gives the Secretary of State the power to appoint a lead enforcement authority to oversee enforcement across the country" (p.10); the government "will keep the operation of the new regime under review to ensure it functions as intended" (p.11) [1] A power to appoint a watchdog is not a duty to appoint one, and "under review" carries no date by which the review reports

A deadline that became an aim

The Committee was specific about why a fixed clause mattered: the draft Bill, as published in January 2026, left the date the £250 cap takes effect to be "decided by ministers," and the Committee wanted that discretion removed, replaced by an automatic trigger two months after Royal Assent (p.9) [1]. The government's answer does not quibble with the two-month figure on its merits; it says outright that fixing any date in the Bill "would not allow sufficient time to complete essential implementation activity," listing further secondary legislation under the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022, new guidance, and work with the courts and enforcement bodies (p.9) [1].

Each of those reasons may be genuine. What the response does not do is turn any of them into a new fixed date. "We will aim to bring the cap into force six months after Royal Assent, while ensuring that the new system will function in a robust and workable manner" (p.9) [1] is an aspiration, not a clause. The commencement power stays with ministers exactly as the Committee objected to, the only change is the number attached to the government's own stated intention, and that number is three times what the Committee asked for.

A cap that depends on an authority that may never exist

The ground rent cap only holds if it cannot be routed around, which is what Recommendation 3 was about: landlords attributing ground rent to parking spaces or similar appurtenant property, or dressing it up inside a headlease, to keep charging above £250 (p.10) [1]. The government's response sets out a real, substantive fix for the definitional loophole: it will amend the "dwelling" definition in the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022, which currently reads "a building or part of a building occupied or intended to be occupied as a separate dwelling, together with any yard, garden, outhouses and appurtenances belonging to it" [3], to close the parking-space route (p.10) [1].

But the response also leans on a second mechanism for enforcement generally: "the Bill also gives the Secretary of State the power to appoint a lead enforcement authority to oversee enforcement across the country" (p.10) [1]. A power to appoint is not an appointment, and the response gives no date by which the Secretary of State intends to use it. The same page says any remaining gap in the regime will be handled because the government "will keep the operation of the new regime under review to ensure it functions as intended" (p.11) [1], with no fixed point at which that review is due to report. A loophole-closing promise with a real legal mechanism behind it sits next to an enforcement promise with a discretionary power and an open-ended review behind it.

Credit where due

The government's response is not evasive about its reasoning: it lists the actual implementation steps, secondary legislation, new guidance, and preparing enforcement bodies and courts, that it says a fixed two-month deadline would not allow time for (p.9) [1]. On the definitional loophole, it goes further than simply noting the problem: it commits to a specific legislative fix, amending the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022's definition of a dwelling, rather than leaving that gap to guidance or discretion alone (p.10) [1]. It also commits to publish a detailed Implementation Roadmap, naming a timeline for secondary legislation and guidance, before Royal Assent (p.9) [1], even though that roadmap itself carries no date yet.

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes. The Committee asked for a binding deadline precisely because the draft Bill left the date at ministers' discretion; the government's response keeps that discretion and replaces the deadline with a target three times as long. And the mechanism meant to stop the cap being evaded rests partly on an enforcement authority the Bill only permits the Secretary of State to appoint, not requires, with no date and no fixed review point attached. A reform this large, worth billions in value transfer to leaseholders on the government's own modelling, would carry more weight if either the commencement date or the enforcement authority were fixed in the Bill rather than left as an aim.

The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, the Committee's Recommendation 2 asked for a statutory commencement clause bringing the £250 ground rent cap into force two months after Royal Assent, removing ministerial discretion over the date; the government's response calls this "not feasible," keeps the commencement power for itself, and promises only to "aim" for six months after Royal Assent (p.9), a non-binding target three times the length asked for. Second, the response's answer to ground-rent-cap avoidance through appurtenant property or headleases rests in part on "the power to appoint a lead enforcement authority" (p.10), a discretionary power rather than a duty, with the wider regime left to be "kept under review" (p.11) with no date by which that review reports. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named official; the criticism is confined to the government response document's own wording and the legal mechanisms it describes. All three sources below were fetched directly on 20 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200, except the committees.parliament.uk press coverage of the original report, which returns HTTP 403 to automated fetches (Cloudflare bot mitigation); its existence and date were independently confirmed via the committees-api.parliament.uk JSON endpoint instead.

Sources

  1. Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill: Government response to pre-legislative scrutiny by the Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, CP 1716, published 19 November 2026
  2. Pre-legislative scrutiny of the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, 1st Report, HC 40, Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee, published 27 May 2026 (committees.parliament.uk's own pages return HTTP 403 to automated fetches; confirmed via the committees-api.parliament.uk JSON endpoint)
  3. Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022, section 22, legislation.gov.uk
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail