The Civil Aviation Authority is raising ATOL charges from April to fund a new enforcement unit. The bill creating those powers has not passed, and the regulator cannot yet prove the money worked.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. The Civil Aviation Authority opened a consultation on 9 November 2026 proposing to raise ATOL and airline charges by 6.8 to 11.6 percent from 1 April 2027, funding a ten-strong enforcement team "for new direct enforcement powers" [1]. Those powers depend on the Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill, which the consultation's own timeline marks as commencing only "subject to legislative timetable" [1]; Parliament's own records show the bill at report stage in the Commons on 10 November 2026, not Royal Assent [2]. The same document says a number of its own success measures "remain under development" [1]. Two documented mistakes, four stars.
The CAA regulates a market it describes, in its own words, as having carried "a record breaking 302 million passengers" to, from or within the UK in 2025, with the ATOL scheme providing financial protection to "more than 31 million passengers" buying protected package holidays each year [1]. On 9 November 2026 it launched its annual consultation on statutory charges, this time proposing a bigger-than-usual rise: an 8 percent increase to its overall charging revenue, worth an extra 12.4 million pounds, with "most charge payers" facing roughly 6.1 percent, according to its own press release [3]. Tracey Martin, the CAA's Chief Financial and Operating Officer, framed it as continuity: "Our mission to protect people and enable aerospace means ensuring the UK aviation sector continues to benefit from effective and efficient regulation" [3].
Buried inside that average is a much larger, and more interesting, targeted rise. Section 5.5 of the consultation document, "Consumer Protection," proposes an 11.6 percent increase to Airline Operator and Economic Regulation of Airports variable charges and a 6.8 percent increase to the ATOL Scheme of Charges, funding a 1.8 million pound "Investment Requirement" with 15 new specialist roles [1]. The stated driver is explicit: "Civil Aviation Bill (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform)" [1].
The charge starts before the power does
The consultation does not claim these are ordinary efficiency charges. It says the Government "has concluded that the CAA's existing consumer enforcement powers are constrained by reliance on court-based processes, which can be time-consuming, resource-intensive and less flexible than the administrative enforcement regimes available to many other UK regulators," and that the bill "would provide the CAA with direct administrative enforcement powers, including the ability to impose financial penalties and other interventions" [1]. Ten of the fifteen new roles form "a dedicated enforcement team responsible for investigations and the exercise of new direct enforcement powers"; the remaining five "strengthen ATOL compliance and enforcement capability," under an item the document calls "CAA readiness for civil enforcement of ATOL regulations," funded on a "Recurring" basis from "FY2027/28 onwards" [1]. The CAA's own press release goes further, describing "new civil sanctions capabilities" among the proposals [3].
Those powers do not exist yet. The Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill started in the House of Lords and is now before the Commons; Parliament's Bills API records its current stage as report stage in the Commons, last updated 10 November 2026, with the bill not yet an Act [2]. It still has to clear the rest of its Commons stages, return to the Lords for consideration of amendments, and receive Royal Assent before the CAA can use anything the consultation describes. The consultation's own Implementation Timeline table lays out four phases of recruitment, governance-building and staff training across FY2027/28, each with a fixed quarter. Only the final phase has no quarter attached: "Commencement and operation of new enforcement powers," against the condition "Subject to legislative timetable" [1]. The consultation's own risk table, two pages earlier, lists "Delay to Civil Aviation Bill" as a live risk to the programme, with "phased capability development" offered as the mitigation [1]. The charge itself carries no such caveat: it is proposed to take effect on 1 April 2027 regardless of where the bill then stands.
A result the CAA cannot yet measure
The consultation sets out an "Expected Outcomes and Success Measures" table for the consumer protection investment, covering implementation readiness, consumer protection capability, compliance monitoring, enforcement readiness, consumer outcomes and industry outcomes [1]. Underneath it, in the section headed "Measuring Success," the document says plainly: "As the legislative framework continues to develop, a number of these measures remain under development, and some are dependent on future policy and implementation decisions. The CAA will continue to refine its performance framework as arrangements mature and operational experience is gained under the new regime" [1]. No baseline figure, target date or threshold is attached to any of the six outcomes listed. Charge payers start funding the enforcement unit from the first day of the next financial year; the yardstick for whether that unit is working is, by the CAA's own account, still being written.
The claims, tested
| The CAA's own words | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| The investment funds "CAA readiness for civil enforcement of ATOL regulations" and "the exercise of new direct enforcement powers," recurring from FY2027/28 [1] | Parliament's own Bills API shows the enabling bill at report stage in the Commons on 10 November 2026, not Royal Assent [2]; the consultation's own timeline marks commencement of the powers "subject to legislative timetable," the only phase with no fixed date [1] | The charge for the powers is fixed; the powers themselves are not |
| "Success will ultimately be assessed through the CAA's ability to implement the new framework effectively, improve compliance, support consumer confidence and deliver proportionate, evidence-based regulation" [1] | The same document says "a number of these measures remain under development, and some are dependent on future policy and implementation decisions" [1], with no baseline or target given for any of the six listed outcomes | Charge payers fund the unit before the CAA has a finished way to check whether it worked |
Credit where due
The consultation does not hide either gap; both the bill's unfinished passage and the unfinished performance framework are stated in the CAA's own words, in the document it is asking the industry to respond to, rather than left for a reader to discover elsewhere. The 1.8 million pound figure is broken down to the role, with ten posts tied specifically to enforcement and five to ATOL compliance, which is a more granular account of what new money buys than most regulators publish in a charging consultation. And the CAA's wider affordability framing, that its total regulatory cost base equates to under 54 pence per passenger and about 0.1 percent of sector turnover, is presented as context for the overall 6.1 percent average rise, not as a description of the much larger 11.6 and 6.8 percent targeted increases, which the document states separately and clearly [1].
Verdict
Four stars, two documented mistakes. The CAA is asking the industry it regulates to start paying, from a fixed date, for an enforcement team built around powers that do not yet exist in law, while its own risk table acknowledges the bill creating them could slip. And it is asking for that money against a success framework it has already told readers is unfinished. Neither point is hidden. Both would matter to any ATOL holder or airline reading the consultation's own figures before it closes on 21 December 2026 [4].
The star score counts two documented mistakes. First: the 1.8 million pound consumer protection investment, including a ten-person enforcement team, is charged on a recurring basis from FY2027/28, but the direct enforcement powers it is built to use depend on the Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill, which Parliament's own Bills API records at report stage in the Commons on 10 November 2026, not Royal Assent; the consultation's own Implementation Timeline marks commencement of the powers "subject to legislative timetable," the only phase in the table without a fixed quarter. Second: the consultation's own "Measuring Success" section states that a number of its performance measures "remain under development" and are "dependent on future policy and implementation decisions," with no baseline or target date given for any of the six listed outcomes. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named CAA official; the quoted remark from the CAA's Chief Financial and Operating Officer is cited as the organisation's public position, not assessed as personal performance. All sources below were fetched directly on 11 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.
Sources
- Statutory Charges FY2027/28 - Consultation document (CAP3324, PDF), Civil Aviation Authority, November 2026
- Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill [HL], Bills API, UK Parliament
- UK Civil Aviation Authority consults on 2027/28 charges, Civil Aviation Authority, press release, 9 November 2026
- CAA Statutory Charges Consultation 2027-2028, Civil Aviation Authority, consultation landing page, opened 9 November 2026, closes 21 December 2026