The regulator running two million daily bank-transfer fraud checks has promised to review the rule in five years. It never mentions that the Bill abolishing the regulator reaches committee stage this week.
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
In short. On 22 October 2026 the Payment Systems Regulator published PS26/2, removing the expiry date from the direction that makes most payment providers run Confirmation of Payee, the account name-check behind more than two million bank-transfer checks a day [1]. In the same breath it commits: "We will review the regulatory requirement to provide CoP in five years to make sure it is still necessary and proportionate" [1]. Nowhere does it mention that the government confirmed in April 2026 it will abolish the PSR and transfer its functions to the FCA [2], or that the Bill doing it reaches Commons committee stage on 24 November, two days after this piece was checked [3]. The PSR's own annual plan, published seven months earlier, already called this a year of change for the regulator making the promise [4]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Confirmation of Payee is the check that flashes up a name-match warning before a bank transfer goes through, introduced in stages since 2019 to cut misdirected payments and authorised push payment fraud. Specific Direction 17 made it compulsory for most payment service providers from October 2022, with every directed firm required to deliver it by 31 October 2024. That direction carried its own expiry date, set for 1 November 2026, nine days after PS26/2 was published [1].
The PSR's reasoning for acting was straightforward: let the direction lapse and the providers it covers lose any regulatory obligation to keep running the check, weakening coverage just as it has become the default. More than 320 organisations now run CoP, representing over 99 percent of the organisations that initiate Faster Payments, and more than two million checks happen every day [1]. So the PSR removed the expiry date. The direction, now numbered 17a, stays in force "until we vary or revoke it," with a promised five-year look-back to check it is still needed [1].
The claims, tested
| The document's own words | What the public record actually sets out | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "We will review the regulatory requirement to provide CoP in five years to make sure it is still necessary and proportionate" (para 1.7, repeated at 2.1, 2.14 and 3.14) [1] | HM Treasury confirmed in April 2026 that it will abolish the PSR and transfer its functions to the FCA, with transitional provisions moving "pre-existing PSR requirements, technical standards, other legal instruments, and guidance" across (para 2.14) [2]. The Financial Services and Markets Bill carrying that change reached its Commons committee stage on 24 and 26 November 2026, with daily amendment papers still being filed [3] | A five-year institutional promise, made in the regulator's own voice, with no mention of whether that regulator will exist to keep it |
| PS26/2 frames the five-year review as routine, business-as-usual regulatory housekeeping, with no reference to the PSR's own institutional situation [1] | The PSR's own Annual Plan and Budget 2026/27, published in March, calls it "a time of change for the Payment Systems Regulator," says staff are "already working under the FCA's operational structure" as "part of a phased transition," and commits only to "preserving the independence of the PSR until we are legally consolidated" (foreword) [4] | The regulator knows how to flag its own uncertain future when it chooses to. It did not choose to here |
A promise with no named owner
Nothing in PS26/2's 11 pages, including its consultation-response section answering the question of whether and when a review should happen, mentions the FCA, consolidation, or the Bill at all. The document was published after the Bill had already cleared every Lords stage and had its First Reading in the Commons on 15 September 2026 [3]. By the time the PSR wrote "we will review," Parliament had already spent five months processing the legislation that would decide who "we" would be.
That matters because the transfer HM Treasury has set out is not automatic housekeeping. The consultation response commits to moving "pre-existing PSR requirements, technical standards, other legal instruments, and guidance" to the FCA, and says the FCA "will then determine its approach under the new legislative framework" (para 2.14) [2]. Whether the FCA honours a five-year clock set by a body it has absorbed, resets it, or simply never revisits a rule it inherited rather than wrote, is left to the FCA to decide once the PSR is gone. PS26/2 does not raise that question, let alone answer it.
The regulator's own words say otherwise
The gap is sharper set against the PSR's own public voice elsewhere. Its Annual Plan and Budget 2026/27, signed off by Managing Director David Geale and published in March 2026, is explicit that the organisation is mid-transition: "We have made good progress on consolidating the PSR into the FCA... Many of our staff are already working under the FCA's operational structure to deliver our work, as part of a phased transition" (foreword) [4]. The same document says the PSR is "drawing down and reducing our reserves ahead of consolidation with the FCA" and commits only to "preserving the independence of the PSR until we are legally consolidated," not beyond it (foreword) [4]. "Supporting consolidation with the FCA" is listed as a named priority for the year, "a critical priority for the coming year" in the plan's own words [4].
So the PSR, writing about its budget and work programme, readily describes itself as an organisation whose independent existence has a visible end point. The same organisation, seven months later, writing a policy statement that happens to set a five-year clock, describes itself as though no such end point exists. Both things can be true: the direction can validly outlive the body that wrote it, since the requirement attaches to Faster Payments, not to the PSR's org chart. What is missing is the one sentence that would have told two million daily users of this protection, and the firms required to deliver it, who is actually accountable for the promise being kept.
Credit where due
The underlying decision is sound and the stakes are correctly read. Letting SD17 lapse on 1 November, nine days after this statement, would have handed every directed payment provider a regulatory off-ramp from a check that now covers effectively the entire Faster Payments market. The PSR consulted properly first, asking directly whether and when a future review should happen, and eleven respondents answered; the five-year backstop, with an earlier review if developments warrant it, was the PSR's considered response to that feedback, not an invented number [1]. Removing the deadline for a protection this widely relied on, instead of letting it expire by default, is the correct call on the merits.
Verdict
Four stars, from two documented mistakes. The decision at the heart of PS26/2 holds up: CoP needed to keep running, and removing an arbitrary expiry date was the right fix. The gaps are both about ownership, not substance. First, a five-year institutional commitment is made without once naming who, in practice, will still be there to honour it, despite the transferring legislation already being five months into its parliamentary passage when the statement was published. Second, the PSR's own annual plan, published by the same regulator seven months earlier, already treats 2026/27 as a year its independence will not survive unqualified, making PS26/2's silence a choice rather than an oversight.
The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, PS26/2 (22 October 2026) commits in the PSR's own voice to review the Confirmation of Payee requirement "in five years" with no mention anywhere in the document of the government's confirmed plan, set out by HM Treasury in April 2026, to abolish the PSR and transfer its functions to the FCA, or of the Financial Services and Markets Bill carrying that change, which reached Commons committee stage on 24 November 2026; second, the PSR's own Annual Plan and Budget 2026/27, published in March 2026, already describes the organisation's independence as temporary ("preserving the independence of the PSR until we are legally consolidated") and lists FCA consolidation as a named priority for the year, a framing PS26/2 does not carry over. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named official; the PSR's decision to remove SD17's expiry date is treated on its merits as correct, and the criticism is confined to the absence of any named accountability for the five-year commitment. All four sources below were fetched directly on 19 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.
Sources
- PS26/2: Specific Direction 17 (Confirmation of Payee), removing the expiry date, Payment Systems Regulator, October 2026
- A Streamlined Approach to Payment Systems Regulation: Consultation response, HM Treasury, April 2026
- Financial Services and Markets Bill [HL], UK Parliament, Bills API
- Annual plan and budget 2026/27, Payment Systems Regulator, March 2026