TEARDOWN Published 12 November 2026 at 06:38. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

McCormick's $44.8 billion takeover of Unilever's food arm threatens Britain's dry sauces and mixes, the CMA says, while clearing mustard outright. Precedent shows the fuller reasoning surfaces only after the deadline to settle has passed.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

25 Cabot Square, a tall glass office building in Canary Wharf, London, photographed from across the dock.
25 Cabot Square (The Cabot), Canary Wharf, London, headquarters of the Competition and Markets Authority. Photo: The wub / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

In short. On 11 November 2026 the Competition and Markets Authority found a "realistic prospect" that McCormick's near $45 billion takeover of most of Unilever's foods business will substantially lessen competition in dry ingredient mixes and, separately, dry sauces to UK retailers [1]. The same decision clears mustard outright, finding English, French and American styles form three separate markets with "no overlap" between them [1]. The parties have until 18 November 2026, one week, to offer undertakings or face referral to Phase 2 [1], and the CMA's own case page says the full text of the decision "will be published shortly" with no date attached [2]. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

McCormick, the US spice group behind Schwartz and French's, is buying most of Unilever's global foods business, the home of Knorr, Maille and Colman's, in a deal CNBC reported on 31 March 2026 as worth "nearly $45 billion", with $15.7 billion of that in cash [3]. On 11 November 2026 the CMA published its phase 1 verdict: a "realistic prospect of a substantial lessening of competition (SLC) as a result of horizontal unilateral effects in the supply of dry ingredient mixes and separately, the supply of dry sauces to retailers... in the United Kingdom" [1]. Unless the parties offer acceptable undertakings by 18 November 2026, the CMA will refer the deal for an in-depth Phase 2 investigation [1].

One ingredient, three markets. Two others, one market each

The CMA's published summary is most detailed exactly where it clears the deal. On mustard, paragraph 15 records that "McCormick supplies American style mustard under the French's brand and Unilever supplies English style mustard under the Colman's brand, as well as French style mustard under the Maille brand," and that "evidence from large supermarkets indicated that end-consumers typically do not consider English, French and American style mustards to be suitable alternatives to one another" [1]. On that specific, sourced evidence, "each of the different types of mustard form separate product markets and there is no overlap between the Parties' products" [1].

Dry ingredient mixes and dry sauces get no equivalent breakdown. Paragraph 6 names "dry ingredient mixes (eg chilli con carne)" and "dry sauces (eg parsley sauce)" as the two categories the CMA examined, each treated as a single UK-wide market [1]. Paragraph 14 explains why competition suffers within those markets, the merger combines "the two largest branded suppliers" into "the largest supplier of dry ingredient mixes and dry sauces by far," with rivals such as Maggi and Bisto only a "limited constraint" [1]. What it does not explain is why a chilli con carne mix and, say, a white sauce mix belong in the same market when English, French and American mustard do not belong in one. The published summary gives mustard a consumer-substitution test by style; it gives mixes and sauces no equivalent test by recipe or cuisine, on the page that is public.

A week to settle, a decision still to be written

The case page's own account of 11 November 2026 ends on an admission: "The full text of the decision will be published shortly" [2]. That "shortly" sits against a hard deadline running the other way: the parties have until 18 November 2026 to offer undertakings in lieu of a reference, after which the CMA either accepts them or refers the merger to Phase 2 [1].

The CMA's own recent record suggests which comes first. In the Macquarie Asset Management and Energy Assets Group merger inquiry, the CMA announced its phase 1 SLC decision on 25 September 2026; by 9 October, fourteen days later, it had already decided the undertakings offered "might be accepted"; the full text decision, containing the market-definition reasoning behind the original finding, was not published until 27 October, eighteen days after that [4]. On that precedent, the full reasoning behind the McCormick/Unilever split, the detail that would let a competing supplier, a retailer or a reader test whether mixes and sauces really are single markets, is unlikely to be public before the week given to settle this case has already run out.

Credit where due

The mustard finding is not a shortcut: it rests on specific evidence gathered from large supermarkets about how shoppers actually treat the three styles, not assumption. The case has also moved on schedule, from pre-notification through an invitation to comment, launch and decision, with no slippage against its own statutory timetable. And the CMA does not hide the gap behind the summary: it states plainly, in its own words, that fuller reasoning is still to come, rather than letting the three-page document pass as the whole story.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the record shows Verdict
Mustard forms "separate product markets" because supermarket evidence shows shoppers do not treat English, French and American styles as substitutes [1] Dry ingredient mixes and dry sauces, each spanning distinct recipe types such as chilli con carne mixes and parsley sauce, get no equivalent substitution test in the published summary [1] One product category is split on sourced evidence; the others are not, on the page that is public
"The full text of the decision will be published shortly" [2], alongside a 18 November 2026 deadline for undertakings [1] In the CMA's most recent comparable case, the full text decision was published 27 October 2026, eighteen days after undertakings were already provisionally accepted on 9 October [4] On the CMA's own recent practice, the reasoning tends to arrive only after the case is already settled

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes, both visible by comparing what the CMA published against its own recent casework rather than by second-guessing its conclusions. The decision gives mustard a specific, sourced reason for standing as three separate markets, then applies no equivalent test to the dry mixes and sauces it finds more concerning. And the week it has given McCormick and Unilever to fix that concern is very likely to close before the fuller reasoning behind the finding is public at all, if the CMA's own Macquarie precedent holds. None of this means the SLC finding is wrong. It means the public case for it, for now, is three pages long.

The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, the published summary gives mustard a specific, evidence-based reason for forming three separate markets by national style, but applies no equivalent substitution test to dry ingredient mixes or dry sauces, each of which spans distinct recipe types (chilli con carne mixes, parsley sauce) named in the CMA's own examples; second, the case page states the full text decision "will be published shortly" with no date, while the parties face a hard 18 November 2026 deadline to offer undertakings, and the CMA's own most recent comparable case (Macquarie Asset Management / Energy Assets Group) saw its full text decision published eighteen days after undertakings were already provisionally accepted, suggesting the reasoning behind this decision is unlikely to be public before this case is effectively settled. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding that the CMA's substantive conclusions, the SLC finding on dry mixes and sauces, or the clearance of mustard, are wrong; both rest on evidence the summary describes. The finding is narrower: on the document published so far, one category gets a sourced market-definition test and two do not, and the fuller reasoning for all three is due only after the week given to resolve the case. Checked directly against the CMA's Summary of phase 1 decision (gov.uk, fetched and read in full 12 November 2026) and the case pages for this inquiry and for the Macquarie/Energy Assets precedent (gov.uk, fetched 12 November 2026).

Sources

  1. Anticipated Acquisition by McCormick & Company, Inc. of the foods business of Unilever PLC: Summary of the phase 1 decision (PDF), Competition and Markets Authority, published 11 November 2026
  2. McCormick / Unilever merger inquiry, Competition and Markets Authority, case page updated 11 November 2026
  3. McCormick buys Unilever's food business in deal that values it at nearly $45 billion, CNBC, published 31 March 2026
  4. Macquarie Asset Management / Energy Assets Group merger inquiry, Competition and Markets Authority, case page
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail