TEARDOWN Published 18 November 2026 at 08:16. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The Ministry of Justice admitted in 2020 that narrowing a damages law might leave a gap. That gap opened, and this month's second fix is exactly as narrow.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes

102 Petty France, the brutalist Ministry of Justice headquarters building in Westminster, London.
102 Petty France, the Ministry of Justice's headquarters, Westminster, 3 May 2023. Photo: Matt Brown / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

In short. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026, made 16 November and in force since 17 November, adds a third narrow exception to section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act so a social worker can finally claim damages for a Family Court judge's "manifestly unfair" handling of her case [1]. When the Ministry of Justice made the same kind of narrow fix in 2020, Parliament's own human rights committee warned it was "likely" that "situations would arise, albeit rarely," where the gap would reopen, and recommended ministers "go further" [7]. They did not. The gap reopened exactly as warned, and this Order fixes it with another exception just as tightly drawn, while admitting in its own paperwork that "the instrument does not include a statutory review clause" [2]. A wider review the government promised in May 2026 "should not be delayed" opened its call for evidence on 16 November, the day before this Order took effect, and will not report to the Committee until Spring 2027 [6]. Two documented failures: four stars.

A Remedial Order is a rare instrument. Section 10 of the Human Rights Act lets a minister amend primary legislation by statutory instrument, bypassing the normal route through a bill, but only where a court has found UK law incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights and the minister can show "compelling reasons" for moving fast [2]. It exists for exactly this situation: a gap in the law that a court has already ruled must close. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026 is only the second one made against section 9(3) of the Act, the provision that limits damages for a judicial act done "in good faith" [1]. The first, made in 2020, was meant to close this problem for good. It did not, and the paper trail shows the government was told it would not.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the record shows Verdict
The Explanatory Memorandum states the Order's purpose is to amend section 9(3) "to compensate a person for a judicial act that is incompatible with Article 8... on the ground that the act was done in such a procedurally defective way as to amount to a breach of the requirements of procedural fairness" [2] This is the third exception written into section 9(3) since the Act was passed: Article 5(5) in 1998, an Article 6 detention exception added in 2020 after Hammerton v UK, and now this Article 8 exception after SW v UK [3] [7] Each exception is drafted to fit the facts of the one case that forced it, not the underlying defect in section 9(3)
"The Government has not conducted a separate consultation exercise as it would not be proportionate to do so for a targeted amendment" [2] When the Committee scrutinised the 2020 Order for the same provision, it told the Ministry of Justice directly: it "considered it likely that situations would arise, albeit rarely," where section 9(3) "even if amended as proposed, would deprive an individual of an effective remedy," and that "it would have been open to the Government to go further" [7] The narrow-fix approach was not an untested assumption when it was repeated in 2026; it was a specifically foreseen risk, foreseen by the government's own adviser on the same provision
"The instrument does not include a statutory review clause" [2] The Joint Committee's 2025 report on this Order concluded "it cannot realistically be argued that section 9(3) would be compatible with Article 13" under the narrow drafting proposed, and recommended the Order "be amended either to set out properly articulated categories of cases... or to remove it entirely" [4] The instrument that just repeated the pattern the Committee warned about also has no built-in mechanism to check whether the pattern repeats again

What actually happened to the person this Order is named for

SW was a social worker in the UK for over a decade before 2014, when she gave evidence as a professional witness in care proceedings concerning alleged child sexual abuse [7]. The Family Court judge rejected the abuse allegations and, in an oral "bullet point" judgment delivered without warning at the end of the hearing, found that SW had been "the principal instigator in a joint enterprise to obtain evidence to prove the sexual abuse allegations," had "lied to the court," and had "subjected one of the children involved to a high level of emotional abuse" [7]. She had no opportunity to respond to any of this before the judge delivered it. He then directed that his findings be sent to the local authority currently employing her and shared with every other local authority she had worked for and with her professional regulator [7]. She was told her assignment had ended the same day the findings reached her employer [7].

Two years later the Court of Appeal set the findings aside, ruling the judge's process "manifestly unfair to a degree which wholly failed to meet the basic requirements of fairness" [7]. Her regulator, the Health and Care Professions Council, cleared her entirely, finding "no credible evidence to suggest that your fitness to practise is currently impaired" [7]. None of that got her compensation. Section 9(3) barred a Human Rights Act claim for a judicial act done in good faith, and misfeasance in public office required proof the judge intended her harm, which nobody alleged [7]. A psychiatrist later recorded that receiving the judge's findings had been a "highly traumatic experience" that triggered post-traumatic stress disorder; she has not been able to work since [7]. The European Court of Human Rights found a breach of Article 8 and, because no domestic remedy existed, a breach of Article 13 too, and ordered the UK to pay EUR 24,000 in damages and EUR 60,000 in costs [7].

The warning that came true

SW's case is not the first time section 9(3) has produced this result. In Hammerton v UK, decided in 2016, the Court found the same provision left a man wrongly detained in contempt of court proceedings with no route to damages [7]. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2020 fixed that by adding a narrow exception covering only detention cases [3]. The Joint Committee on Human Rights scrutinised that 2020 Order at the time, and the SW judgment itself records exactly what the Committee said, citing its report directly: the Committee welcomed the fix "which in its view addressed the specific finding by the Court in the case of Mr Hammerton," but it "expressed concern that the terms of the Order were drawn too tightly and would not do enough to prevent future similar violations of Article 13," and "considered it likely that situations would arise, albeit rarely," where the amended section 9(3) "would deprive an individual of an effective remedy for a breach of a Convention right." The Committee's conclusion was direct: "it would have been open to the Government to go further," and it "recommended that the Minister consider whether alternative drafting could give better effect to removing the incompatibility" [7].

The government did not go further. SW's case had, by that point, already been working through the domestic courts for years; the Court of Appeal ruled in her favour in November 2016, the same year as Hammerton, and the ECtHR delivered its own judgment on her case in June 2021 [7]. The Joint Committee's prediction that further violations were "likely" was not a hypothetical warning about an abstract future case. It came true for a case that was, by the time the Committee wrote it, already most of the way to Strasbourg.

The Committee made the same point again in its 2025 report on this very Order, this time in starker terms. It noted that the Ministry of Justice had, in 2020, itself "acknowledged that because the new section 9(3)(b)... only extended to circumstances similar to those in the Hammerton case, there could be rare but possible circumstances where the effect of section 9(3) would be to create a further breach of Article 13. That has now happened in the SW case" [4]. Faced with the government's proposal to add a third narrow exception rather than address the structural problem, the Committee did not mince words: "it makes little sense to continue adding narrow exceptions to the statutory restriction on the availability of damages for judicial acts. The more exceptions there are to section 9(3), the more arbitrary the provision becomes" [4]. It recommended the Order be amended to set out properly articulated categories of case, "or to remove it entirely" [4].

The review that arrived a day too late

The Ministry of Justice's formal response to that report, published in May 2026, declined both options. Broadening the exceptions or repealing section 9(3) "may have unintended consequences," it said, and would need "significant consultation with relevant parties, including the judiciary and devolved governments" [5]. Instead, it made a specific commitment: "we will undertake a wider review of how section 9(3) HRA is operating separate to the implementation of this judgment, which should not be delayed" [5].

Six months passed before that review opened. The "Section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 Review: terms of reference" was published on 16 November 2026, a call for evidence running eight weeks, scoped to look "solely" at section 9(3) and conducted by "a small team of MoJ officials" [6]. The review does not commit to a fix, or even a decision; it commits only to "writing to the JCHR setting out what action it plans to take in relation to section 9(3) HRA in Spring 2027" [6]. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026, carrying the narrow fix the review was meant to examine before it was made permanent, came into force the very next day, 17 November 2026 [1]. A review the government itself said "should not be delayed" took exactly as long to open as the drafting work on the narrow fix it was supposed to inform, and will not report for another four months after that, by which time a third documented warning about the same provision will already be in force as law.

Credit where due

The government did not ignore the Committee outright. Its May 2026 response accepted several of the Committee's drafting recommendations in full, simplifying the wording of the new exception and fixing two points the Committee flagged, including capitalising "Application" in the footnote reference to the SW case to match the 2020 Order's style [5]. It also did what section 10 requires without shortcuts: a document containing the proposed Order was laid before Parliament, the Committee's representations were received and answered in a published statement, and the final draft was approved by resolution of both Houses before being made [1] [5]. And the underlying judgment is not in dispute: SW suffered a real, serious breach of her rights, and after more than a decade without a remedy, this Order finally gives her one [7]. The government's caution about broadening a provision that touches judicial immunity, a principle it is entitled to treat carefully, is a defensible position to hold. The gap is not that ministers acted in bad faith. It is that they chose, with their own adviser's 2020 warning already proven right, to make exactly the same choice a second time, and then to launch the review that might have avoided a third only after the choice had already been made.

The star score counts two documented failures, not misstatements: first, the Order repeats, in a document the government itself drafted, a narrow-exception approach the Joint Committee on Human Rights warned in 2020 was "likely" to leave future cases without a remedy, a warning the SW judgment itself records came true; second, the Explanatory Memorandum admits "the instrument does not include a statutory review clause," and the wider review the government promised in May 2026 "should not be delayed" did not open its call for evidence until the day before this Order took effect, reporting only a recommendation, not a fix, in Spring 2027. Two failures in the 1-to-3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about the conduct of any named individual; the Family Court judge in the SW case is referred to only by his role, consistent with the Court of Appeal's own anonymised judgment, and the Committee's and Ministry of Justice's positions are quoted from their own published words. All seven sources below were fetched directly on 18 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200, except source 4, which returns HTTP 403 to automated requests (a known block on publications.parliament.uk's own HTML pages) and was independently verified live via a 16 November 2026 archived snapshot, read in full before citing.

Sources

  1. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026, made 16 November 2026, in force 17 November 2026
  2. Explanatory Memorandum to the Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026, Ministry of Justice
  3. The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2020, made 29 September 2020
  4. Proposal for a Remedial Order to amend the Human Rights Act 1998: Judicial Immunity, Eighth Report of Session 2024-26 (HC 1406), Joint Committee on Human Rights, published 27 October 2025
  5. Response to the Joint Committee on Human Rights' eighth report of session 2024-2026: Proposal for a Remedial Order to amend the Human Rights Act 1998: Judicial Immunity, Ministry of Justice, May 2026
  6. Section 9(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998 Review: terms of reference, Ministry of Justice, published 16 November 2026
  7. Case of S.W. v. the United Kingdom (Application no. 87/18), European Court of Human Rights, 22 June 2021
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail