TEARDOWN Published 14 November 2026 at 06:48. Evidence-based. Source-cited. No sponsored content.

The government wants new powers to let the Charity Commission disqualify trustees who promote extremism. Its own consultation shows that power already exists, and was used to remove one in 2019.

4 out of 5 stars4/52 documented mistakes in this teardownHow ratings work

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Government Offices Great George Street, London, part of which houses the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport.
Government Offices Great George Street, London, 2011. 100 Parliament Street, the eastern end of this building, is DCMS's registered address. Photo: Carlos Delgado / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

In short. DCMS's consultation on new Charity Commission disqualification powers, launched 14 October 2026, proposes a new condition letting the Commission disqualify trustees who promote violence or racial or religious hatred [1]. The same-day press release says the measures were developed "drawing on [the Commission's] casework experience of where current rules fall short" [2]. The consultation document's own account of its flagship new condition says the opposite: "To date, the Commission has, in instances where extremism is identified, relied on condition F to satisfy the first limb of the disqualification power test" [1], and its own case study shows that general power being used in 2019 to disqualify a trustee for exactly this kind of conduct, upheld by the Tribunal on appeal. Two documented mistakes: four stars.

The Charity Commission regulates more than 170,000 registered charities in England and Wales with a combined annual income above £90 billion [1]. On 14 October 2026, DCMS launched a ten-week consultation proposing to widen the grounds on which the Commission can strip someone of a trustee or senior management role, adding new criteria tied to hate crime convictions, national security offences, exclusion from the UK, and, the proposal that does the most new legal work, conduct that "promotes or encourages violence, or racial or religious hatred" [1].

Civil Society Minister Vicky Foxcroft framed the need in capability terms: "where people seek to use charities as a platform to promote hatred or violence, we need to make sure the Charity Commission has the powers it needs to act" [2]. Charity Commission chief executive David Holdsworth added that "our powers must keep pace with the changing threats in this area" [2]. The press release itself says the proposals were "developed jointly with the Charity Commission, drawing on its casework experience of where current rules fall short" [2]. The consultation document's own introduction strikes the same note: the Commission "already has a range of powers and takes robust action in cases of extremist abuse, but there is often a high bar that must be met before these powers can be exercised" [1].

What the Commission already does

Read past the introduction, and the document's own account of its headline new condition does not describe a power the Commission lacks. Under "Promotion or encouragement of violence, or racial or religious hatred", it states plainly: "To date, the Commission has, in instances where extremism is identified, relied on condition F to satisfy the first limb of the disqualification power test" [1]. Condition F is the Commission's existing general catch-all, in section 181A(7) of the Charities Act 2011: any past or continuing conduct, whether or not connected to a charity, that is "damaging or likely to be damaging to public trust and confidence in charities" [3]. The document is explicit about what the new, more specific condition would actually change: it "would recognise this conduct as always harmful" and make it "more straightforward for the Commission to remove the ongoing risk" [1]. Straightforward is a word about process, not capability.

The document's own case studies, offered to justify a related proposal on deprivation of citizenship and exclusion, show condition F working in practice rather than failing. In April 2019 the Commission disqualified Dr Zakir Naik from acting as a trustee or senior manager of any charity for 15 years, the maximum duration available, after finding that condition F was satisfied by his conduct [1]. Dr Naik appealed to the First-Tier Tribunal in 2020. The Tribunal upheld the disqualification, reducing the duration to seven and a half years [1]. The document's conclusion from its own case study is not that condition F failed, but that a more specific provision "would have saved time when making the initial decision as well as during the internal review process and appeal process" [1]. A power that produces a disqualification a tribunal upholds, only more slowly, is not a power that is falling short.

Asking the public for the evidence it needs itself

A new condition targeting "the promotion or encouragement of violence, or racial or religious hatred" engages race and religion directly, two of the characteristics protected by the Equality Act 2010 [1]. The consultation's own "Part 3: Equalities impact" section says as much: "When developing a policy proposal, the government must comply with the Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) in section 149 of the Equality Act 2010," which requires government to have "due regard" to eliminating unlawful discrimination and advancing equality of opportunity [1].

The section then states the department's conclusion: "Based on our initial assessment, we do not consider that the new powers constitute unlawful discrimination, harassment, victimisation, or any other conduct prohibited by the Equality Act 2010" [1]. No data, case analysis or methodology for that "initial assessment" appears anywhere in the document; the assessment is the one sentence quoted above. The very next question in the same section, addressed to the public, is: "Do you have any evidence of the equalities impacts, positive or negative, of any of the proposals set out in the consultation?" [1]. A duty to assess equality impact before deciding policy is being discharged, on the document's own showing, by a one-line assertion followed by a request for respondents to supply whatever evidence that assertion should have rested on.

The claims, tested

The document's own words What the same document shows Verdict
The press release says the new powers draw on "casework experience of where current rules fall short" [2]; the consultation's introduction cites "a high bar" before current powers "can be exercised" [1] The consultation's own account of its flagship new condition says the Commission already "relied on condition F" in extremism cases, and its case study shows that power producing a 2019 disqualification the Tribunal upheld on appeal [1] The new condition is framed as closing a capability gap; the document's own evidence shows a working power, and describes the benefit as speed, not reach
"Part 3: Equalities impact" states the PSED requires a due-regard assessment before the policy is decided [1] The department's "initial assessment" is a single unsupported sentence, immediately followed by a question asking the public for "evidence of the equalities impacts" of the same proposals [1] A statutory duty to assess impact before deciding policy is being discharged by asking respondents to provide the assessment

Credit where due

The consultation does not hide the case study that undercuts its own framing; the Naik decision, its Tribunal appeal, and the reduced duration are set out in the document itself, not omitted or softened [1]. The proposals also build in an explicit carve-out for ordinary debate: the new condition "is not intended to capture mere offence or unpleasantness towards an individual or a group of people, or to prevent legitimate debates or speakers, or to interfere with the operation of legal free speech duties in higher education" [1], and both the Minister and the Commission's chief executive spoke publicly about protecting "legitimate debate, campaigning and freedom of expression" [2]. The consultation is still open, closing 23 December 2026, genuinely asking charities, trustees and the public for views before the government decides anything [1].

Verdict

Four stars, from two documented mistakes. Neither mistake is that the government wants stronger safeguards against charities being used to spread hatred; that is a legitimate aim, and the document's own carve-outs for legitimate debate are a serious attempt to bound it. The mistakes are in how the case for new powers is made. A press release and an introduction frame existing rules as falling short, while the consultation's own case study and its own account of current practice show a power that already reaches this conduct and survives appeal. And a statutory duty to assess equality impact before policy is settled is answered with one unsupported sentence, then a question asking the public to supply the evidence for it.

The star score counts two documented mistakes. First, the press release says the new powers draw on Commission "casework experience of where current rules fall short", and the consultation's introduction cites "a high bar" before current powers can be used, while the consultation's own account of its flagship new condition states the Commission already "relied on condition F" in extremism cases and its case study shows that power producing a 2019 disqualification the Tribunal upheld on appeal, with the document's stated benefit of the new condition being speed ("would have saved time"), not reach. Second, "Part 3: Equalities impact" states the Public Sector Equality Duty requires a due-regard assessment before the policy is decided, but the department's "initial assessment" is a single unsupported sentence, immediately followed by a question asking respondents for "evidence of the equalities impacts" of the same proposals. Two falls in the 1 to 3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about whether the five proposed conditions are individually justified, about any named individual's current circumstances, or about the Commission's wider enforcement record, none of which this piece independently tested. All sources were fetched and verified live on 14 November 2026.

Sources

  1. Consultation on the extension of the Charity Commission's powers to tackle extremism, Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, published 14 October 2026
  2. Consultation on powers to protect charities from extremist abuse, Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, published 14 October 2026
  3. Charities Act 2011, section 181A, legislation.gov.uk
SHARE THIS ARTICLEXBlueskyMastodonLinkedInRedditEmail