The Home Office says a court ruling in November 2025 proved its reading of EU residence rules wrong. It took more than ten months to update the rules and guidance, and nothing covers who applied in between.
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
In short. Statement of Changes HC 584 amends the EU Settlement Scheme's pre-settled status rules. The government's own explanatory memorandum says the change follows a Court of Appeal judgment, Ayoola v SSHD [2025] EWCA Civ 1519, and that "the changes reflect that judgment" [1]. The judgment was handed down on 28 November 2025 [2]; the rule it produced did not take effect until 8 October 2026, and the 118-page caseworker guidance that applies it was not updated until the day after that [3]. Neither document says what happens to anyone whose application was decided during the gap. Two documented mistakes: four stars.
Statement of Changes HC 584 was laid before Parliament on 3 September 2026 [4] and makes around thirty separate changes to the Immigration Rules, from visitor visa definitions to the Hong Kong BN(O) route. Most are drafting tidy-ups. One is different: a change to Appendix EU, the rules behind the EU Settlement Scheme, which the government's own explanatory memorandum says exists because a court told it its previous reading of the Withdrawal Agreement was too narrow.
The document's own account
The explanatory memorandum is specific about why the rule changed. At paragraph 5.29 it states: "In Ayoola [2025], the Court of Appeal held that a child who holds PSS and whose EU citizen parent was formerly a worker or self-employed person in the UK has a right of residence under the WA that continues until the completion of their education in the UK. That right is not lost solely because, after the end of the transition period, the child ceases to be a family member of an EU citizen" [1]. The changes "enable such a child who has obtained PSS as a family member to retain their PSS (and go on to qualify for settled status), and will enable their primary carer... to obtain or retain PSS... where this is necessary for the child to complete their education in the UK" [1].
Paragraph 6.7 goes further, setting out the department's own prior position: "It was initially considered that they only applied to those who benefitted from them at the end of the transition period. However, in November 2025, the Court of Appeal ruled that the provisions could be first relied on after the end of the transition period: Ayoola v SSHD [2025] EWCA Civ 1519 (28 November 2025)... The changes reflect that judgment" [1]. The judgment itself concerns "the interpretation of Articles 24 and 25 of the [Withdrawal Agreement]" (paragraph 1), the provisions that let a child of an EU worker or self-employed person finish their education here with their carer present [2]. This piece takes no position on how the Court of Appeal resolved the separate questions argued in that case; the point here is narrower and comes from the government's own paperwork, not an independent reading of the judgment.
A year between the ruling and the rule
By the department's own account, 28 November 2025 is the date its prior reading stopped being tenable. The explanatory memorandum's own commencement section puts the fix into force on 8 October 2026 [1]: more than ten months later. The guidance caseworkers actually use, EU Settlement Scheme: derivative right to reside (Chen and Ibrahim/Teixeira cases), took a day longer still. Its current edition, version 8.0, states under "Changes from last version of this guidance": "Changes have been made to reflect Statement of Changes in Immigration Rules HC 584, laid on 3 September 2026, to include those who become a person with a derivative right to reside after the specified date... in line with Article 24(2) or 25(2) of the Withdrawal Agreement, as confirmed in Ayoola v SSHD [2025] EWCA Civ 1519" [3]. That edition is dated "published for Home Office staff on 9 October 2026" [3], the first version to carry that line.
The explanatory memorandum explains why guidance lags rules rather than leading them: "Guidance relating to these Rules changes will be updated and placed on the GOV.UK website when these changes take effect... It is our practice to only publish guidance updates when Rules changes take effect to mitigate the high risk of users referring to the wrong version" [1]. That practice is designed to stop staff using an out-of-date document. It also means that for the whole of the period the department itself dates from the Ayoola judgment, the only guidance in circulation was the version that predated it.
What the guidance does not say
Nothing in the 118 pages of that guidance, read in full, mentions reviewing, reconsidering or revisiting a decision made before version 8.0 under the superseded reading. No section is headed anything like "cases decided before this update"; no transitional provision appears anywhere in the document. The explanatory memorandum confirms no formal consultation was run on any of HC 584's changes, "as this would be disproportionate given the nature of the changes" [1], and that no full impact assessment was prepared, "because the level of impact and/or type of change being made does not warrant doing so" [1]. A change the department's own account ties to a court correcting its reading of a child's residence rights was not thought to need either.
Credit where due
The explanatory memorandum does not obscure any of this. It names the case, gives the date in full, and states plainly that the rule exists because of it, rather than describing the change in vaguer terms that would have been harder to check. The guidance's "changes from last version" section is equally direct about what prompted the update and when. Both documents make it straightforward to establish the gap this piece describes; neither tries to hide it.
The claims, tested
| The document's own words | What the record shows | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| "The changes reflect that judgment" of 28 November 2025 (explanatory memorandum, para 6.7) [1] | The same memorandum puts the rule into force on 8 October 2026 [1]; the guidance that applies it is dated the day after that [3] | More than ten months separate the judgment the department cites and the paperwork catching up with it |
| Guidance is only updated "when these changes take effect," to avoid staff "referring to the wrong version" (para 8.2) [1] | A full read of the 118-page guidance finds no mention of reviewing decisions made before version 8.0 [3] | The policy that keeps staff off the wrong version says nothing about applicants already decided under it |
The star score counts two documented mistakes: first, more than ten months passed between the Court of Appeal judgment the department's own explanatory memorandum credits for this rule change and that rule, and the guidance applying it, taking effect; second, neither the explanatory memorandum nor the 118-page caseworker guidance it produced says anything about reviewing, reconsidering or otherwise addressing applications decided during that gap under the superseded reading, and no consultation or impact assessment was carried out for a change the department itself ties to correcting its reading of a child's residence rights. Two mistakes in the 1-to-3 band: four stars; the bands are on the ratings page. This piece makes no finding about how the Court of Appeal resolved the separate legal questions argued in Ayoola, nor about whether any individual application was wrongly decided; it reports what the department's own account of the judgment's effect says, and what its own documents do and do not provide for in the period before that account was acted on. All sources below were fetched directly on 17 November 2026 and returned HTTP 200.
Sources
- Explanatory memorandum to the statement of changes in Immigration Rules: HC 584, 3 September 2026 (accessible), Home Office, laid 3 September 2026
- Ayoola v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2025] EWCA Civ 1519, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), handed down 28 November 2025
- EU Settlement Scheme: derivative right to reside (Chen and Ibrahim/Teixeira cases) (accessible), Home Office, version 8.0, published for Home Office staff 9 October 2026
- Statement of changes to the Immigration Rules: HC 584, 3 September 2026, Home Office